• About
  • Calendar
  • Stand for Peace
  • Join
  • Donate
  • Volunteer
  • Contact
  • Issues
  • Mobilizer
  • Blog
  • Peace Allies
  • Action Alerts
Sign In
Sign in Don't have an account? Register now

Pages tagged "Indigenous and First Nations Rights"


Indigenous and First Nations Rights

Posted by Pamela Richard · April 03, 2025 8:47 AM · 2 reactions

Gold mining in the Amazon has doubled in area since 2018, AI tool shows

Fernanda Wenzel
AmazonAmazon Illegal Deforestation
  • An artificial intelligence tool trained to track gold mines through satellite imagery found that the deforestation linked to the activity doubled in the Amazon Rainforest from 2018 to 2023.
  • Mines are widespread in the biome, affecting especially Brazil, Guyana, Suriname, Venezuela and Peru.
  • The spread of gold mines followed a sharp increase in the price of the metal, which nearly doubled since 2018.
  • In Brazil, the federal government has succeeded in reducing the rate at which illegal mining is expanding inside Indigenous territories, but still struggles to block its spread outright.
See All Key Ideas

In 2021, scientists and journalists got together to train an artificial intelligence model on how to detect gold mines in the Amazon. One year later, they launched Amazon Mining Watch, a tool capable of using satellite imagery to identify the scars left by miners in the rainforest. Designed by the Pulitzer Center’s Rainforest Investigations Network, the NGO Amazon Conservation, and Earth Genome, one of the main challenges of the initiative was the inevitable cloud obscuring images of the rainforest.

“[Cloud cover] means that it’s hard to get clear views of what’s happening on the ground,” Edward Boyda, from Earth Genome, told Mongabay. “We look across the whole set of those images, 50 or so per year, and from those we collect the cloud-free ones.”

The endeavor was a success, but the picture they gained isn’t good. According to the methodology, the area occupied by gold mines across the entire Amazon doubled from 2018 to 2023, going from 963,000 to 1.9 million hectares (2.4 million to 4.7 million acres).

Researchers from the Monitoring of the Andean Amazon Project (MAAP) analyzed the data and concluded that most of the mines are located in Brazil (55%) — not surprising since the country accounts for 60% of the entire biome. However, the activity is pervasive in other countries, like Guyana, which accounted for 15% of the total mining areas, Suriname (12%), Venezuela (7%) and Peru (7%).

Journalists and scientists used artificial intelligence to track gold mines in the Amazon Rainforest. Image courtesy of the Brazilian Army.

“It’s absolutely widespread,” Boyda said, adding he was startled by the pace of the destruction. “Mining is expanding in many different places, and many new areas are being opened all the time.”

The spread of gold mines followed a sharp increase in the price of the metal, which jumped from $1,300 per ounce in 2018 to $2,300/oz in 2023. In recent months, it has reached up to $2,461.

Experts state that despite being responsible for the clearance of much smaller areas of rainforest compared to land grabbing and agribusiness, gold mining can have more harmful impacts.

“In contrast with agribusiness, much of the mining happens in intact rainforest,” Boyda said, adding that gold mining is usually the first in a series of predatory activities. “When miners go into these places, they create pathways and airstrips, so there’s a real concern that this primary activity leads down the road to much more widespread deforestation for agriculture and other land uses.”

Moreover, gold mining usually happens on riverbanks, and the destruction of entire layers of soil makes it almost impossible for the forest to regenerate on its own. Miners also use mercury to separate the gold from the ore, contaminating the water consumed by Indigenous and riverine communities. In Brazil, most mercury is illegally obtained.

“You’re left with a kind of a moonscape. You have toxic sludge pools where there was healthy rainforest before,” Boyda said. “The local environmental impacts of this are particularly dire.”

Brazil’s President, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, in white, created a task force to expel illegal miners from the Yanomami Indigenous Territory as one of his first orders of business. Image by Ricardo Stuckert/PR via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0).

Brazil’s Indigenous lands still under pressure

One of the most emblematic cases of the spread of gold mining in the Amazon, according to the MAAP report, is the Yanomami Indigenous Territory, located in the border region of Brazil’s Amazonas and Roraima states. Artificial intelligence tracked a total of 19,000 hectares (47,000 acres) cleared for gold mines in this territory, which, under the country’s Constitution, is supposed to be off-limits to mining. More than 90% of this deforestation occurred in the past five years.

That boom began with the administration of Jair Bolsonaro, an unapologetically pro-mining president who was in office from the start of 2019 until the end of 2022. The illegal mining in the Yanomami territory reached a crisis point where the number of invading miners almost equaled the 30,000 Indigenous inhabitants.

The illegal activity spawned a humanitarian crisis, with Indigenous children dying from malnutrition and malaria. This generated international headlines in 2023, and prompted the new president, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, to create a task force to expel the invaders.

Despite the government’s efforts, however, illegal mining has continued to advance in the territory, albeit at a slower rate, thanks to the support of criminal organizations. In the six first months of 2024, about 170 hectares (419 acres) of forest in the Yanomami Indigenous Territory were cleared for gold mines, down nearly 6% compared to the previous year.

The numbers come from a Greenpeace report published in mid-July, which concluded that the illegal miners are migrating from the north to the south of the vast territory, which covers an area nearly the size of South Korea. “The satellite images clearly show that the illegal miners, trying to evade inspection, are heading for the southern part of the territory, closer to the Amazonas state,” the organization said in the report.

Greenpeace also looked at the Kayapó and Munduruku Indigenous lands. Together, these three territories accounted for 90% of all illegal mining inside Brazilian Indigenous lands by the end of 2023. “These are some of the areas most affected by illegal mining,” Jorge Dantas, Greenpeace Brasil spokesperson, told Mongabay. “So we understand that if the government manages to provide a consistent response to mining in these regions, it can replicate this success elsewhere.”

The report concluded that miners destroyed 417 hectares (1,030 acres) of forest in these three territories in the first half of 2024. The Kayapó Indigenous Territory, in Pará state, has also been the scene of police raids, which have contributed to deforestation rates linked to gold mining dropping by 60% from the previous year. Even so, 227 hectares (561 acres) of the territory have been cleared for mining this year.

“You have fewer openings, but it’s noteworthy that the miners continue to operate,” Dantas said. “There’s been an increase in operations, but the illegal miners are still able to sophisticate their methods and continue to open up new areas.”


Haskell Indian Nations University: "Trail of Broken Treaties" Continues with "Efficiency" Firings

Support Tribal Colleges and Students: Please Call Your Elected Officials

 Script:

  •  I am a supporter of tribal college education and the American Indian College Fund.
  • Haskell Indian Nations University and Southwestern Indian Polytechnic Institute, the Nation's oldest and only federally chartered Tribal Colleges are in a crisis due to the implementation of EO 14210 and the White House memo on hiring freezes.
  • In the last week, each institution lost over 24 percent of its staff - including student safety personnel and instructors. 
  • This is preventing the colleges’ ability to provide courses, programs, and student support services—and interfering with students’ completion of a higher education they paid for.
  • I am requesting that Haskell and SIPI be exempted from the hiring freeze and terminated employees terminated due to EO 14210 be reinstated.
  • CAPITOL SWITHCHBOARD: 202-224-3121


Radiation Exposure: Uranium Mining and Transport Issues on the Navajo Reservation in Arizona:

https://bsnorrell.blogspot.com/2025/02/tuba-city-community-forum-and-walk-shut.html

https://bsnorrell.blogspot.com/2025/02/navajo-nation-dishonors-legacy-of-klee.html

(Klee Benally came to Milwaukee in 2019 for the Peace Action WI sponsored Native American Land Rights Forum.)


Call the Wisconsin Dept of Natural Resources today to protest the approval of Enbridge's 41 mile pipeline extension in Northern Wisconsin. Support Indigenous Water Protectors! 

Call (608) 301 6264, ask for Gregory Pils, Director of the Dept of Environmental Analysis and Sustainability for WI DNR.

New Documentary \

The Anishinabe Bad River Tribe has terminated the contract for the Line 5 pipeline to Canadian dirty oil company Enbridge Oil to cross reservation land. A pipeline extension south of the tribe was recently granted by WI DNR, but it would also cross the Bad River watershed. Oil spewing from a break in the pipeline could be disastrous to the Lake Superior region. The extension would connect two lines of pipe which are 20 years past their service life and could rupture at any time. None of this oil stays in the US, but crosses our land and the Straits of Mackinaw in a corroding pipeline on the way back to Canada.

The DNR gave their approval for the plan only 1 week after the devastating eruption of Line 9 in Oakland, WI that deluged the area with 70,000 gallons of oil.

Protect our clean Wisconsin water!

truthout.org/articles/indigenous-water-protectors-warn-of-line-5-pipelines-looming-dangers/


 

It is our great hope that Pres Biden will grant Clemency.

Join us as we talk about Leonard Peltier and Indigenous Genocide.

REGISTER

#FreeLeonardPeltier


Happy Native American Heritage Month From the Army That Brought You the Trail of Tears

Nick Turse

After 170 years of armed attacks, forced relocations, ethnic cleansing, and genocide of Native Americans, the U.S. military wants to celebrate

 


The Pipestone National Monument in present-day Minnesota is the only place with sacred red pipestone. Medicine people and their Tribes continue the ancient practice of quarrying the stone by hand to carve pipes and continue to use the same area for ceremonies. This is an area with extreme cultural and spiritual significance for the Lakota, Nakota, and Dakota peoples. It has been protected as part of the National Park system with full access to the quarry based on treaties signed long ago. But this sacred place and national monument is under threat from a fossil fuel pipeline.

Sign now to appeal the approval of the dangerous Magellan Pipeline reroute.


STARTS AT HARTFORD AND DOWNER AT ELECTA QUINNEY FIRE CIRCLE

Tell your U.S. Rep: vote in favor of justice for radiation victims

Send an email to urge your U.S. Representative to re-initiate and expand RECA. For greater impact, please personalize this sample text.

The RECA program provides health screenings and financial assistance to those harmed by exposure to radiation by the U.S. nuclear weapons program. Thousands have been denied compensation for decades in the original RECA, which took effect in 1990 and expired in June of this year.  In March, Senators Josh Hawley (R-MO) and Ben Ray Lujan (D-NM) successfully passed RECA expansion in the Senate (S. 3853) by a wide, bipartisan margin. However, Speaker of the House Mike Johnson (R-LA) has refused to schedule a vote on S. 3853 in the House.

 "This is not a partisan issue and we should never view it that way — and to actually tell us that the reason for not passing the bill is that it's going to cost too much — when we have spent trillions of dollars on our nuclear arsenal — is obscene," said Tina Cordova, Tularosa Basin Downwinders Consortium.


KPFA Broadcast on Alcatraz
Mission Local

Thousands gather for Indigenous Peoples’ Day sunrise ceremony on Alcatraz

by Abigail Van NeelyOctober 14, 2024, 11:48 am
  • A group of people holds flags near an outdoor fire at night.A person holds a Palestinian flag at a nighttime gathering with a group of people in the background.      Palestinian flags fly above the bonfire on Alcatraz Island for Indigenous Peoples Day A person in traditional attire with a feathered headdress stands amid a crowd holding flags, with a ruined building in the background. Smoke is visible in the foreground.
Aztec dancers perform at the annual sunrise gathering for Indigenous Peoples' day on Alcatraz Island. Photo on Oct. 14, 2024 by Abigail Van Neely.

While the rest of the city slept, Alcatraz glowed as thousands circled around a bonfire lit on the island in honor of Indigenous Peoples’ Day.

The annual sunrise gathering began before dawn on Monday to commemorate the original occupation of Alcatraz island by “Indians of All Tribes” between 1969 and 1971. Organizers from the International Indian Treaty Council say that action “sparked the National and International Indigenous Peoples movement for rights and justice.”

A dancer in traditional attire performs at an outdoor event, with a crowd watching in the background.
A dancer at the Indigenous Peoples’ day sunrise gathering on Alcatraz Island. Photo on Oct. 14, 2024 by Abigail Van Neely.

This year, the event drew around 2,500 people, council liaison Morning Star Gali estimated. The crowds did not shy away from an early morning boat ride.

The council’s executive director, Andrea Carmen, arrived around 2:30 a.m. to set up for the dozens of indigenous performers who would sing and dance from 5 to 9 a.m. as the night sky faded into a cloudy gray behind them. 

Aerial view of a large group of people gathered in a circle near the water, with some in colorful attire performing in the center. Dense greenery can be seen in the background.
Aztek Teokalli dancers, seen from the top of Alcatraz Island on Oct. 14, 2024. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.

The Golden Gate Bridge remained obscured by fog. A sign on the former prison, meanwhile, shone, lit by floodlights amid the darkness. It had been painted over to read “United Indian Property” during the initial occupation. 

People in colorful traditional attire dance in a large outdoor area, with a crowd watching and rocky landscape in the background.
Volunteer dancers spin around the bonfire on Alcatraz Island. Photo on Oct. 14, 2024 by Abigail Van Neely.

For four hours, the volunteer musicians and dancers swirled around the blaze at the center of a growing ring of spectators. Indigenous leaders highlighted their fight against climate change and led collective prayers. Guests of honor included tribal elders and veterans of the original occupation.  

Many attendees wore keffiyeh scarves. Palestinian flags were brought out for a portion of the gathering, when dancers led audience members around the crackling fire to chants of “Free Palestine.” 

Employees of the ferry-boat operator, City Experiences, also stood in solidarity with indigenous leaders. The workers, who are on strike, were permitted to provide service to the island on Monday, when almost 200 free tickets were provided to community members by the organization Indigenous Justice. One employee added that they hoped to provide free ferry tickets to all indigenous people in the future. 


Ferries carrying members of the public began departing just after 4 a.m. Despite the early hour, the boats buzzed with chatter. From one deck, someone played music from a speaker. Though some attendees traveled from as far away as British Columbia, many came from San Francisco, saying they were there to support the indigenous “land back” efforts. “We should re-occupy it,” one said as their ferry approached the island. 

Many had personal ties to native tribes, like Brandon Smith, who runs a fencing school in North Beach and is connected to the Yoeme tribe in Arizona. It was his first time visiting Alcatraz. 

A group of people gather outdoors near a large fire, with some wearing traditional attire and others watching. Flags are displayed in the background.
Barefoot performers dance at the annual Indigenous People’s sunrise gathering. Photo on Oct. 14, 2024 by Abigail Van Neely.

It had been a particularly emotional week leading up to this year’s gathering, Gali said; the council had just lost two elders. But, on this morning, the positive warmth Gali said she felt was palpable as other community members approached to embrace her from the audience. She predicted an even larger crowd of 5,000 for the next sunrise gathering on Nov. 28.

“Alcatraz represents both a site of pain where Indigenous Peoples were imprisoned for their resistance to colonization, and a place where we stood up together for our rights and survival.” a spokesperson from the council wrote in a statement. “This annual gathering honors those resistors and reminds us that our fight for justice is far from over.” 

Before European settlers arrived in California, local tribes had varying relationships with the island. But once the U.S. expanded into California, Alcatraz island became a military base where indigenous people were incarcerated, according to the Sogorea Te’ Land Trust.

Person in traditional clothing holds colorful feathers, wearing a beaded yellow garment and headdress with feathers, face painted, standing outdoors.
Flags reading “no more stolen sisters” fluttered above participants of the annual sunrise gathering for Indigenous Peoples’ day on Alcatraz Island. Photo on Oct. 14, 2024 by Abigail Van Neely.

As attendees waited to board boats leaving the island for San Francisco, Gali announced that the microphone was now open to anyone who wanted to “share a song” or “talk about their peoples’ struggles.” 

Meanwhile, tourists visiting Alcatraz began to arrive. When a park ranger mentioned the island’s occupation more than 50 years ago, the crowd roared. 

People in traditional attire perform a cultural dance outdoors, with a rocky cliff in the background and a seated audience watching.
Dancers enter the circle of people gathered for Indigenous People’s day as the sun rises behind the clouds over Alcatraz Island. Photo on Oct. 14, 2024 by Abigail Van Neely.
A person in a colorful outfit and headdress dances outdoors near a fire, with a crowd watching in the background.
A dancer at the annual sunrise gathering for Indigenous Peoples’ day on Alcatraz Island. Photo on Oct. 14, 2024 by Abigail Van Neely.
A person with braided hair, adorned with beaded hair accessories, wears a patterned shawl with red and white ribbons, standing among a group of people.
Many sunrise gathering attendees on Alcatraz Island wore keffiyeh scarves. Photo on Oct. 14, 2024 by Abigail Van Neely.
A person wearing a headdress with red and green feathers, patterned fabric, and a nose ring is participating in a cultural event.
An Aztek Teokalli dancer at the sunrise gathering on Alcatraz Island. Photo on Oct. 14, 2024 by Abigail Van Neely.
Three men hold flags with feathers, standing outdoors in winter clothing. A crowd is visible in the background.
Guests of honor at the Alcatraz sunrise gathering included tribal elders and veterans of the original occupation. Photo on Oct. 14, 2024 by Abigail Van Neely.

Abigail Van Neely

[email protected]

Originally from New York City, Abigail is a recent graduate of Stanford's Journalism Master's program. She's interested in climate, community, and accountability stories, and enjoys foggy mornings with her tuxedo cat, Sally Carerra (yes, the shelter did in fact name the cat after the Porsche from the animated movie Cars).



Missiles on our Rez

Ella Weber, a Princeton student and member of the Madan, Hidatsa and Arikara Nations, discovers the at there are nuclear missiles on her reservation.

https://missilesonourland.org/podcast.html


Protect The Porkies in Northern Michigan

September 14th: Gichigaming Water Walk

 The Gichigami Water Walk, organized by members of the Bad River and Menominee Tribal Nations in collaboration with Protect The Porkies, will take place on Saturday, September 14th.

 Nibi (the Anishinaabe word for Water) will be carried from the Montreal River at the Michigan/Wisconsin border in Ironwood to the shores of Lake Superior in the Presque Isle Scenic Area of Porcupine Mountains State Park. The route will take us through the towns of Ironwood, Bessemer, and Wakefield, and past the proposed Copperwood mine site. The total distance is 31 miles.

  1. Friends in Wisconsin, please come greet us this Saturday at the Ashland Farmers Market!
  2. You can find campaign postcards and posters here — in addition to being beautiful works of art, the offering of these items is an important fundraising tool for the campaign.
  3. You can find a replay of our July 30th Town Hall with Ben Price regarding the Great Lakes Bill of Rights here. Ben gave a wonderful presentation (starting around minute 24:00), and in the months to come we are excited to continue building momentum towards the legal recognition of Rights of Nature in the Upper Peninsula and beyond.

Although the Gichigami Water Walk is being organized in response to proposals for new metallic sulfide mines in the Lake Superior watershed — specifically, the Copperwood Mine and the reopening of the White Pine Mine (the original having been defeated in large part by the Bad River Train Blockade) — it’s important to note that the Water Walk is not a protest: it is a ceremony to honor our connection to the Land, Water, and all the diverse Lifeforms with whom our own wellbeing is intertwined. Through our steps, we will offer prayers of protection for all these entities. 

The Walk is scheduled to commence at 8 a.m. CT and conclude at 5 p.m CT, to be followed by a Feast and Speakers in the State Park picnic area. Through the use of SPOT tracking technology, we will make it easy to find and join the Walk at any point throughout the day.

In order to facilitate the most successful Water Walk possible, as well as to subsidize expenses such as travel costs and lodging for high priority tribal members, we have launched a fundraising page. We would be grateful for any contributions.

Media will be permitted to cover the event, with the exception of certain sensitive moments, such as the opening and closing water ceremonies.

You can find current information at the Gichigami Water Walk event page, which will be updated regularly. Please note, in order to facilitate planning in this remote area with limited amenities — as well as to keep all participants properly informed — an RSVP is requested (though not mandatory).

In solidarity,
Tom Grotewohl

www.ProtectThePorkies.com


Joint Statement on the Legacy of Nuclear Weapons
General Debate of the 2024 NPT PrepCom
Delivered by H.E. Ambassador Teburoro Tito, Permanent Representative of Kiribati
22 July 2024

"I have the honor to deliver this statement on behalf of Egypt, Fiji, Kazakhstan, Marshall Islands,
Philippines, Samoa, Vanuatu, and my own state, Kiribati. This statement was prepared in
consultation with affected communities from Kazakhstan, the Marshall Islands, and Kiribati........
"Due to the growing call from the international community to address the legacy of nuclear
weapons, we, as States Parties to the NPT, must urgently take action to help communities
impacted by nuclear weapons and remediate contaminated environments."


These communities, primarily Indigenous Peoples living near the nuclear test zones, never
provided consent for their territories to be used as test sites.
Alarmingly, these tests also caused widespread humanitarian and environmental harm beyond
the affected States’ national borders."


Joint Statement of States Parties to the South Pacific Nuclear Free Zone Treaty

2024 Preparatory Committee for the 2026 Review Conference of the Parties to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, 22 July 2024, Geneva.

Delivered by New Zealand

1. Thank you Chair.

2. It is my honour to deliver this statement on behalf of States Parties to the South Pacific Nuclear Free Zone Treaty, also known as the Treaty of Rarotonga: Australia, Cook Islands, Fiji, Kiribati, Nauru, New Zealand, Niue, Papua New Guinea, Samoa, Solomon Islands, Tonga, Tuvalu, and Vanuatu.

3. The Treaty of Rarotonga was adopted in 1985 in response to the devastation of decades of nuclear testing in our region. The Treaty established the world’s second zone of its kind in a populated area, and contained an additional provision prohibiting the dumping of radioactive waste and radioactive matter in the South Pacific Nuclear Free Zone.

4. The Treaty of Rarotonga stands as a symbol of our region’s steadfast opposition to nuclear weapons. The scars of nuclear testing continue to mark our people and environment, and reinforce to our countries the unacceptable humanitarian costs and risks posed by nuclear war.

5. Our Zone is a concrete contribution to international disarmament and non-proliferation efforts. We speak today at this Preparatory Committee to reaffirm our commitment to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) and its objectives. We express our deep concern at the lack of progress on disarmament, and repeat here the call made by States Parties to the Treaty of Rarotonga at the 2022 NPT Review Conference for all nuclear-weapon States to implement their disarmament obligations under Article VI of the NPT and honour the commitments made, including those emanating from past NPT Review Conferences.

6. We also reaffirm our commitment to all review pillars of the NPT. Our members, in adopting the Rarotonga Treaty, recognised the linkages between the three pillars. Indeed, our Treaty contains a provision requiring States Parties to “support the continued effectiveness of the international non-proliferation system based on the NPT and the IAEA safeguards system”.

7. The safe and secure shipment of radioactive material remains important to our region and to our Blue Pacific. We again strongly urge all non-nuclear weapon States to fully comply with the NPT requirement to accept safeguards on peaceful nuclear activities, and all related international law obligations relating to nuclear safety, to ensure the prevention of harm to our ocean, particularly from radioactive disasters and the transboundary spread of radioactive material and radioactive waste.

8. I reiterate our Leaders’ urging for the United States to ratify all Protocols to the Treaty of Rarotonga. We previously welcomed the announcement by the US of its intention to do so and look forward to indications of progress in this regard.

9. Given the legacy of nuclear testing in our region, I also take this opportunity to highlight the importance of the entry into force of the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty. I repeat our call made for the remaining States to sign and ratify the Treaty, in particular those States whose ratification is required to bring the Treaty into legal effect.

10. I note the 2021 entry into force of the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons and its second meeting of States Parties to the Treaty in late 2023.

11. States Parties to the Rarotonga Treaty stand resolutely committed to a nuclear weapon-free world. It is our firm hope that this Preparatory Committee makes progress to this end.


Missile Silo Construction Could Threaten Sacred Sites

BY JAMES GIAGO DAVIES, LAKOTA TIMES 
 
JULY 17, 2024

CHEYENNE, WY— Last week the United States Air Force (USAF) met with various tribal representatives at Warren Air Force Base to discuss the upcoming Minute Man Missile construction, and how that construction might negatively impact tribal cultural sites. This meeting was addressed over the weekend at the Great Plains Tribal Chairman’s Association (GPTCA) meeting in Rapid City.

Oglala Sioux Tribal Attorney Mario Gonzalez is perhaps the leading expert on the 1851 Treaty, and how stipulations therein impact any silo construction plans by the USAF.

All that area down there is our aboriginal area,” Gonzalez told LT. “It’s Cheyenne area, but we used that area, too, so there’s a lot of Lakota sites down there around Cheyenne. There were meetings down there with the THPOs (Tribal Historic Preservation Officers). A meeting was held at Warren AFB with the Air Force, two or three days ago. The Air Force had invited like fifty tribes to come in there and help with the survey.”

Despite the large scope of the invitation, Gonzalez does not find the tribal presence at that meeting adequate. This was expressed a few days after at the GPTCA meeting in Rapid City.

“At the (GPTCA) meeting there was a little concern by the chairmen that they are not being informed about (the Missile Silo construction). They are really concerned that the THPOs are not providing information to the tribes. That was expressed by (OST President) Frank Star Comes Out as chairman of the GPTCA, saying our leadership isn’t being provided information by these THPOs so we don’t know what’s going on.”

In 1966 Congress passed the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) which required federal agencies to evaluate the impact of all federally funded or permitted projects on historic properties. State Historic Preservation Officers (SHPOs) were created to facilitate this process. These SHPOs soon extended their authority into tribal areas where the states had no authority, and they were ignorant of how to identify let alone protect tribal sacred sites. For this reason, Tribal Historic Preservation Officers (THPOs) were created, largely through the advocacy of Standing Rock’s Tim Mentz, who became the nation’s first THPO. Mentz told a Bureau of Land Management (BLM) consultation panel some years back that many archaeologists trample right over sacred rock features and don’t even recognize them. Mentz gave a powerpoint presentation on this concern that so impressed BLM they asked him to come to their main offices and present it there.

“We have every right to say what is important to us,” Mentz said. “The SHPOs have a national group. They were fighting us…saying the tribes don’t have any rights outside reservation boundaries, on tribal land and federal land, to say what is important to them.”

But once THPOs were in play, Mentz said that changed: “We took away from the states as having jurisdiction over anything that had a federal dime, federal involvement, federal attachment, and federal assistance, even.”

Like Gonzalez, Mentz points out that the 1851 Fort Laramie treaty boundary, of 66 million acres, is the express interest of THPOs. The problem, as Star Comes Out pointed out this weekend, is that the THPOs are not informing the tribal chairmen of what took place at the meeting down in Cheyenne, or that there even was a meeting down in Cheyenne, or that this meeting addressed the possible threat to tribal sacred and historic sites, known or yet discovered.

Mentz was the first to uncover the inherent weakness in the THPO system. In over a decade on the job, he became the leading expert on THPOs as well, but his own tribe no longer wants him at THPO meetings. Mentz understands all too well how the THPO can abuse and profit from his position. Instead of protecting the tribe, the THPO draws his THPO salary, he then collects a consultation fee from the archeology firm hired to assess the impact at various sites. The THPO comes to understand if he signs off favorably, he not only collects a fee, any buddies he hires to help him arrive at that favorable assessment, also collect a fee. While many THPOs across the country exemplify THPO purpose and integrity, enough do not that the tribes are not properly informed about the activities or threats of tribal sacred sites on federal land.

The USAF has big construction plans to upgrade 450 Minute Man III missile silos, and they have set up meetings and extended invitations, realizing tribes will take issue with many aspects of that upgrade. But the THPOs have not informed the tribes adequately, and many of the tribal leaders do not know enough about any threat to act effectively without THPO;s running point.

“I had to explain,” Gonzalez said, during his participation at the GPTCA meeting, “that the 1851 Treaty recognized title to 60 million acres but there is also aboriginal Indian title which is based on use and occupation for a long time, all the way to Colorado. We wintered down in those areas. In fact, the treaty says that the Sioux reserve the right to hunt on the Republican fork of the Smoky Hill River in Colorado, as a winter ground, that’s Spotted Tail, he insisted that be in there. Chief Smoke’s people wintered down in the Fort Collins, Loveland and Denver area. I think Chief Smoke even wintered on Cherry Creek in downtown Denver. The state of Colorado is writing the Sioux out of the history of the state. That was a joint aboriginal use area. The Sioux used some of that area more so than the Cheyenne. I explained that to (the GPTCA) at the meeting so they could understand it a little better, why we are involved down there in Cheyenne, Wyoming, why there are meetings held at Warren AFB with the with Air Force, to comply with NEPA (National Environmental Policy Act) and NAGPRA (Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act). NEPA isn’t stand alone, you have to look at it in conjunction with other acts, including NAGRA, ARPA (Archeological Resources Protection Act), including the Endangered Species Act. All of those acts now have to be looked at in conjunction with NEPA itself.”

USAF’s Lt Colonel James Dawkins said, “We’re having to go to those sites that have already have equipment and decommission them, dig some of it away, destroy some of the facilities, and then put new facilities where those old facilities were. And so, this is the challenge. If you’re going to do one per week for nine years, that’s what the average is, that’s quite a big level of work.”

Tribes are concerned that all the digging and destroying might threaten unidentified sacred sites, and the chairmen want their THPOs to be on the ball, not only informing them of the situation with the silo upgrades, but faithfully executing their duties and properly and comprehensively identifying vulnerable sacred sites.

(James Giago Davies is an enrolled member of OST. Contact him at [email protected])


LEONARD PELTIER DENIED PAROLE

  • By People's Dispatch.
  • July 3, 2024

Above photo: Peltier’s supporters rally in front of Federal Building in Rapid City, South Dakota, on June 27.  Angel White Eyes, Photo Editor for NDN Collective.

Longest-Held Political Prisoner In United States And Indigenous Freedom Fighter Continues To Maintain Innocence.

The federal Parole Commission has denied Leonard Peltier’s request for parole, Peltier’s legal team announced on Tuesday, July 2. This marks a major setback for the longest-held political prisoner in the United States, who had his first parole hearing in over a decade on June 10.

Peltier, who was active in the American Indian Movement (AIM) and a beacon for both the Indigenous struggle in the United States and the struggle to free political prisoners, now will continue to languish in prison for an undetermined amount of time. According to Peltier’s lawyer, Kevin Sharp, an interim hearing has been scheduled for 2026, while a full hearing has been scheduled for June 2039, when Peltier will be 94.

Peltier’s best hope at getting out before he dies is a presidential pardon by Biden, a move which many previous presidents have refused to make on Peltier’s behalf, in part due to significant pressure by the FBI, which has waged a decades-long campaign to keep Peltier in prison for allegedly killing two FBI agents. To this day, Peltier maintains his innocence.

“​​Today is a sad day for Indigenous Peoples and justice everywhere,” said Nick Tilsen, president and CEO of the NDN Collective, an Indigenous organization that has been fighting to free Peltier. “They denied parole to a survivor of genocidal Indian boarding schools as he struggles to survive this unjust incarceration, they insist on holding him for a crime for which they have no physical evidence against him. Clearly, the Parole Commission—which is supposed to be an independent body – was influenced by the FBI. The FBI continues to abuse its power, promote false narratives, and engage in counterintelligence activities. The FBI has no regard for the Constitution or the laws they have sworn an oath to protect.”

Peltier suffers from various ailments due to his confinement in close quarters. Peoples Dispatch spoke to Gloria La Riva, who ran alongside Leonard Peltier in the 2020 US presidential elections on the ticket of the Party for Socialism and Liberation, about Peltier’s condition. “Leonard is confined in a small cell, most of the time being on lockdown, where he can’t even walk properly and have circulation and sunshine and proper food,” she said. Peltier contracted COVID-19 in 2022, and currently has untreated kidney disease, among other ailments. Kevin Sharp has suggested that this was probably Peltier’s “last chance” at parole.

PLEASE JOIN US FOR THE
18TH PROTECTING MOTHER EARTH CONFERENCE
 
REGISTRATION IS NOW OPEN to the Indigenous Environmental Network’s 18th Protecting Mother Earth Conference, hosted by the Eastern Band of Cherokee, from August 1 to 4, 2024.
 
Protecting Mother Earth (PME) Conferences are all-outdoor events, and this year, the theme will be Indigenous Just Transition. We will gather on the Qualla Boundary, located in the mountains of what is now known as Western North Carolina, the original homeland of the Cherokee Peoples. 
 
This is a free, outdoor event (registration required) with the expectation that guests (if able) will camp on-site.
 
The PME is Indigenous-initiated, organized, and led to elevate the critical voices of those fighting the frontline battles against the violation of our treaty rights, self-determination, environmental injustice, and climate change. We welcome Indigenous Peoples, frontline grassroots groups, and tribal nation representatives – allies and CJ/EJ advocates across Turtle Island.
 
The 4-day event will include plenaries and break-out sessions addressing the following key themes:
 
  • Climate Justice
  • Extreme vs. Renewable Energy
  • Mining
  • Indigenous Relationship Jurisprudence (IRJ)

  • False Solutions to Climate Change
  • Food Sovereignty
  • Environmental Health
  • Indigenous Just Transition
  • Rights of Nature / Mother Earth
 
Click here to register
 
You will need to bring:
  • Camping gear: tent, sleeping bag/bed roll.*
  • Camp chairs and blankets for seating at various events and entertainment.
  • To limit single-use plastics and waste, we ask that everyone bring their own dishes, eating utensils, cups, and water bottles.
  • Bath towels, flashlights, and non-toxic personal hygiene products.
  •  Medication and other personal items while attending the PME.
We provide: 
  • Comfort stations; showers and restrooms. 
  • Daycare will be provided during the day’s events. Parents are expected to retrieve your children during mealtimes and share meals with them. 
  • Meals. Special diets will be honored as much as possible. If your dietary needs are highly specialized, be prepared to provide these for yourself. 
  • Wellness tents, snacks, and drinks will also be available.
  • Limited travel scholarships will be offered by application, encouraging community support for ground travel accommodations when possible.
*Limited camp gear will be available for those unable to transport their own. These will be reserved on a first-come, first-serve basis.
 
If campfires are allowed on site, the firewood will be provided. Please do not bring firewood to prevent the spread of pests and pathogens.
 
Please leave pets at home. We will allow verified emotional support and service companions within reason.
 
Firearms, drugs, and alcohol are strictly prohibited while attending the conference and on the property where the PME is being conducted.
 
Click here to register
 
Please stay tuned for updates: volunteer sign-up, travel scholarships, ride-share, and additional information as the 18th Protecting Mother Earth Conference days draw closer.  
 
We sincerely hope you can join us for our event!
 
For more info email: [email protected]

logo

 Missing and Murdered Indigenous People

As tribal communities and organizations across Indian Country prepare to observe the National Day of Awareness for Missing and Murdered Indigenous People (MMIP) in early May, the need for amplifying awareness of this crisis has never been more urgent. 

Originally focused on missing and murdered women Native women (MMIW), the acronym has evolved to MMIP to include girls, boys, men and two spirits who have all been affected by this tragic epidemic. 

The significance of the National Day of Awareness is deeply rooted in the story of Hanna Harris, a 21-year-old member of the Northern Cheyenne tribe who went missing in July 2013.  The Montana congressional delegation advocated for the establishment of May 5 — which was Hanna’s birth date — to honor her and highlight the urgency of the MMIP crisis. 

Recent data from the Congressional Research Service paints a stark picture of the violent victimization experienced by American Indian/Alaska Native (AI/AN) men, with 82% reporting such experiences in their lifetimes. Nearly 3.5% of missing persons in the national database of missing persons were identified as AI/AN — significantly higher than their representation in the overall U.S. population. 

Recent events, such as the tragic disappearance and death of Lakota actor Cole Brings Plenty, the nephew of Yellowstone star Mo Brings Plenty, highlight the urgency of addressing the MMIP crisis in Indian Country. And it reminds us that there is still work to be done.   

Protect Thacker Pass

  Lithium Mine Destroying Sacred Indigenous Land in Nevada

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Thacker Pass Protectors File First-Ever “Biodiversity Necessity Defense” in Nevada Court
Also pursuing “Climate Necessity Defense” and making allegations that mining company has violated their rights. Attorney: “They’re not criminals; they’re heroes.”
WINNEMUCCA, NV — In a first for the American legal system, the lawyers for six people sued by Lithium Nevada Corporation for protesting the Thacker Pass mine are arguing a ‘biodiversity necessity defense.’
The necessity defense is a legal argument used to justify breaking the law when a greater harm is being prevented; for example, breaking a car window to save an infant locked inside on a stifling hot day, or breaking down a door to help someone screaming inside a locked home. In these cases, trespassing is justified to save a life.
This week’s filing states that “Defendants possessed an actual belief that their acts of protest were necessary to prevent the present, continuing harms and evils of ecocide and irreversible climate change.”
“We’re in the midst of the 6th mass extinction of life on Earth, and it’s being caused by human activities like mining,” said attorney Terry Lodge, who is representing the protesters. “Our lives are made possible by biodiversity and ecosystems. Protecting our children from pollution and biodiversity collapse isn’t criminal, it’s heroic.”
Currently Earth is experiencing one of the most rapid and widespread extinction events in the planet’s 4-billion-year history.
Biologists report that habitat destruction, like the bulldozing of nearly 6,000 acres of biodiverse sagebrush steppe for the Thacker Pass mine, is the main cause of this “6th Mass Extinction.”
Permitting documents for the Thacker Pass mine show the project will harm or kill pronghorn antelope, golden eagles, mule deer, migratory birds, burrowing owls, bobcats, roughly a dozen bat species, various rare plants, and hundreds of other species.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is currently being sued by environmental groups in an attempt to secure protection for a rare snail species who lives in Thacker Pass and who are threatened with extinction.
“Our ancestors fought and died for the land at Peehee Mu’huh,” says Dean Barlese, an elder and spiritual leader from the Pyramid Lake Paiute Tribe who is one of the defendants in the case. “We’ve acted for the coming generations to protect Mother Earth.”
In their court filing earlier this week, Lodge and the other attorneys working on the case made several additional legal arguments, including invoking the doctrine ‘unclean hands,’ asserting that Lithium Nevada Corporation has “engaged in serious misconduct including violating the Defendants’ human rights, Defendants’ civil rights, misleading the public about the impacts of lithium mining and how lithium mining contributes to climate change and biodiversity collapse, and conducting the inherently dangerous and ecologically-destructive practice of surface mining at the Thacker Pass mine”.
They’re also arguing the “climate necessity defense,” reasoning that by attempting to stop a major mine that will produce significant greenhouse gas emissions, the protesters were acting to reduce emissions and stop a bigger harm: climate change.
According to permitting documents, the Thacker Pass lithium mine is expected to produce more than 150,000 tons of carbon dioxide equivalent per year, roughly equivalent to the emissions of a small city and amounting to 2.3 tons of carbon for every ton of lithium that will be produced.
This legal strategy has been used by many fossil fuel protesters around the world for roughly a decade (and has been successful in a few cases), but this is the first time the same argument has been applied to a ‘green technology’ minerals mining project.
“Lithium Nevada, a mining corporation benefiting from the violence used to conquer Native peoples, is trying to bully peaceful protestors opposing the destruction of that massacre site,” said Will Falk, an attorney and one of the defendants in the case.
“People need to understand that lithium mining companies—like coal or gold mining companies—use racist and violent tactics to intimidate opposition.”
“The Indian wars are continuing in 2023, right here,” Barlese says. “America and the corporations who control it should have finished off the ethnic genocide, because we’re still here. My great-great-grandfather fought for this land in the Snake War and we will continue to defend the sacred. Lithium Nevada is a greedy corporation telling green lies.”
Bethany Sam:
“Our people couldn’t return to Thacker Pass for fear of being killed in 1865, and now in 2023 we can’t return or we’ll be arrested. Meanwhile, bulldozers are digging our ancestors graves up. This is what Indigenous peoples continue to endure. That’s why I stood in prayer with our elders leading the way.”
Bhie-Cie Zahn-Nahtzu:
“Lithium Nevada is a greedy corporation on the wrong side of history when it comes to environmental racism and desecration of sacred sites. It’s ironic to me that I’m the trespasser because I want to see my ancestral land preserved.”
“It is truly outrageous that we live in a society where our Supreme Court has granted constitutional rights to resource extraction corporations, making their destructive activities fully legal and virtually immune from oversight by We the People. Even their right to sue us is a corporate personhood right,” said defendant Paul Cienfuegos, founding director of Community Rights US.
“Lithium mining for electric vehicles and batteries isn’t green, it’s greenwashing,” says Max Wilbert, co-founder of Protect Thacker Pass and author of the book Bright Green Lies: How the Environmental Movement Lost Its Way and What We Can Do About It. “It’s not green, it’s greed. Global warming is a serious problem and we cannot continue burning fossil fuels, but destroying mountains for lithium is just as bad as destroying mountains for coal. You can’t blow up a mountain and call it green.”
Earlier this month, the judge presiding over the case dismissed an “unjust enrichment” charge filed against the protesters, but allowed five other charges to move forward. The case is expected to continue for months.
About the Case
The lawsuit against the protestors was filed in May 2023 following a month of non-violent protests on the site of the Thacker Pass lithium mine in northern Nevada. Thacker Pass is known as Peehee Mu’huh in Paiute, and is a sacred site to regional Native American tribes. It’s also habitat for threatened and endangered wildlife.
Analysts say the lawsuit is similar to what is called a “Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation,” or SLAPP suit, aimed at shutting down Constitutionally-protected free speech and protest. It aims to ban the water protectors from the area and force them to pay monetary damages.
On September 12th, 1865, federal soldiers murdered at least 31 Paiute men, women, and children in Thacker Pass during “The Snake War.”
This massacre and other culturally important factors have made the Thacker Pass mine extremely controversial in the Native American community. Dozens of tribes have spoken out against the project, and four — the Reno-Sparks Indian Colony, Summit Lake Paiute Tribe, Burns Paiute Tribe, and Winnemucca Indian Colony — battled in court to stop the Thacker Pass mine. The National Congress of American Indians has also passed several resolutions opposing the project.
But despite ongoing criticism, lawsuits, and lobbying from tribes as well as environmental groups, ranchers, the Nevada State Historic Preservation Society, and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, both Lithium Nevada Corporation and the Bureau of Land Management have refused to stop construction or change any aspect of the Thacker Pass mine.
In February 2023, the Bureau of Land Management recognized Thacker Pass as eligible for the National Register of Historic Places as a “Traditional Cultural District,” or a landscape that’s very important to tribes. But the very day before, they issued Lithium Nevada’s final bond, allowing the Canadian multinational to begin full-scale mining operations.
#DefendTheLand #HandsOffMcDermittCaldera #ProtectBiodiversity #ProtectTheClimate #Lithium #Mining is #BrightGreenLies

The film "Bad River" opens in AMC theaters in multiple cities across the country on March 15, with Wisconsin screenings in Milwaukee, Madison, Park Falls, and Ashland. 50% of all proceeds from the project will benefit the Bad River Band. 
--The film chronicles the Wisconsin-based Bad River Band and the Band's ongoing fight for sovereignty, which unfolds in a groundbreaking way through a series of shocking revelations, devastating losses, and a powerful legacy of defiance and resilience. This inspiring project brings us through the epic sweep of history into the present, with a David and Goliath battle over a 70-year-old pipeline on the brink of rupture into Lake Superior, the largest freshwater resource in America. 

Milwaukee:

Showtimes at AMC Mayfair, 2500 N. Mayfair Road

Fri. March 15, 2:30, 5:00, 7:30, 10:00
Sat. March 16 12:30, 2:30, 5:00, 7:30, 10:00
Sun. March 17 12:30, 3;00, 5:30, 8:00

Native Bidaské with Patty Loew & Alton 'Sonny' Smart on the Significance of the New Film 'Bad River'

  • Yahoo News
BY NATIVE NEWS ONLINE STAFF 
MARCH 06, 2024

Native News Online Founder and Publisher Levi Rickert sits down with Patty Loew and Alton "Sonny" Smart, members of the Wisconsin Bad River Band of Lake Superior Ojibwe. This discussion will delve into the profound significance of the upcoming film "Bad River” by filmmaker Mary Mazzio.

The fight against the Enbridge Line 5 pipeline is symbolic of the ongoing struggle faced by the Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians to safeguard their ancestral lands and waters. This struggle takes center stage in "Bad River," a powerful new documentary set to premiere on March 15. Narrated by Indigenous activist and model Quannah Chasing Horse, the film promises to be a stirring testament to resilience and resistance.

In our discussion, we'll explore the historical and cultural context surrounding Indian Affairs;  the enduring dependence on the Bureau of Indian Affairs;  and the far-reaching consequences of resource extraction. We'll emphasize the importance of understanding the rich history and culture of the Bad River community, raising awareness, and fostering activism among tribal members to protect sovereignty and cultural preservation.

Patty Loew, an esteemed member of the Bad River Band of Lake Superior Ojibwe, brings her expertise as a professor, author, and documentary filmmaker, focusing on Ojibwe treaty rights, cultural expression, and environmental activism. Meanwhile, Alton "Sonny" Smart, a revered elder of the Bad River Band, will share his insights as a spiritual leader, educator, and Vietnam War Veteran, bridging cultural divides and enriching communities through his unique blend of cultural knowledge and Western approaches.

Catch this enlightening episode of Native Bidaské LIVE airing at Noon ET on Native News Online's Facebook, X (Twitter), or YouTube channel.


Tribes condemn start of uranium mining at Pinyon Plain Mine south of Grand Canyon

    • ADRIAN SKABELUND Sun Staff Reporter

Jan 13, 2024Two northern Arizona tribes this week condemned the start of operations at a uranium mine just south of the Grand Canyon.

The statements came after Denver-based company Energy Fuels Inc. announced last month that operations at its Pinyon Plain Mine had commenced.

“It is with heavy hearts that we must acknowledge that our greatest fear has come true,” a statement from the Havasupai Tribal Council read.

Meanwhile, Navajo Nation President Buu Nygren said in a statement that mining remains opposed “by all neighboring tribes that have forever called Grand Canyon their home.”

The Havasupai Tribe, along with many conservation groups, have long worried that the mine could contaminate area groundwater......


Native American Literary Great N. Scott Momaday (Kiowa) Has Walked On 

N. Scott Momaday (Photo/Facebook)

N. Scott Momaday (Photo/Facebook)

BY LEVI RICKERT  JANUARY 29, 2024

N. Scott Momaday (Kiowa/Cherokee), one of the most prolific contemporary Native American writers, has passed away at his home in Santa Fe, New Mexico. Momaday, who was awarded a Pulitzer Prize for Fiction in 1969 for his debut novel “House Made of Dawn,” was a storyteller, poet, and educator. He was 89.

Momaday is credited with a resurgence of Native American literature and earned his place as the founding member of the “Native American Renaissance.” After receiving the Pulitzer Prize, he wrote “The Way to Rainy Mountain” in 1976.

Throughout his illustrious career, he became known for Indigenous oral tradition, which he taught during his 35 years as an educator. Momaday earned a Ph.D. in English literature from Stanford University and went on to teach at several universities, including the University of California-Santa Barbara and the University of California-Berkeley. He retired as Regents Professor at the University of Arizona.

In 2007, Momaday was presented a National Medal of Arts award by President George W. Bush. At the time of the award presentation, the White House said Momaday was given the award for “for his writings and his work that celebrate and preserve Native American art and oral tradition.”

In 2019, Momaday was featured on a PBS “American Masters” documentary, “Words from a Bear,” in which he discussed his belief he was a reincarnation of a bear connected to the Native American origin story around Devils Tower in Wyoming. The film captured the essence of Momaday’s writing with a strong emphasis on Native American oral history. "Words From a Bear"  was produced and directed by Jeffrey Palmer (Kiowa). 

Filmmaker Jeffrey Palmer with N. Scott Momaday on set of PBS' American Masters "Words From a Bear." (Photo/Courtesy of Jeffrey Palmer)
Filmmaker Jeffrey Palmer with N. Scott Momaday on set of PBS' American Masters "Words From a Bear." (Photo/Courtesy of Jeffrey Palmer)

 

Palmer, who teaches film at Cornell University, told Naive News Online on Monday that he worked with Momaday for three and half years to complete the documentary, which allowed him to spend a lot of time with the author.

"He made Native American literature and storytelling palatable to the rest of the world. He opened countless doors of Native American storytellers," Palmer said. "He was a changemaker and an icon. For the Kiowa people it was profound to see our stories told to the rest of the world. I put Momaday up there with Whitman and Faulkner. He was a great American writer, not only a Native American writer."

Born on February 27, 1934, in Lawton, Oklahoma, at the Kiowa and Comanche Indian Hospital, Momaday’s father was full-blooded Kiowa, and his mother was Cherokee, English, Irish, and French. He spent several years growing up at the Jemez Pueblo in New Mexico, which influenced much of his writing.

In addition to the Pulitzer Prize, Momaday was the recipient of numerous awards and honors, including the Academy of American Poets Prize; the National Medal of Arts; the Ken Burns American Heritage Prize; the Dayton Literary Peace Prize Foundation’s Richard C. Holbrooke Distinguished Achievement Award; and the 2021 Frost Medal for distinguished lifetime achievement in poetry.

BY ELYSE WILD
JANUARY 31, 2024

Join Levi Rickert, publisher of Native News Online on Native Bidaské as he interviews Jeffrey Palmer (Kiowa) on his feature film, "N. Scott Momaday: Words from a Bear." 

On Monday, January 29, 2024, we learned of the passing of N. Scott Momaday (Kiowa) at the age of 89. Momaday is credited for being the founding member of  “Native American Renaissance.” Momaday won a Pulitzer Prize for Fiction in 1969 for his novel “House of Dawn.”

In honor of Mr. Momaday’s passing, we interviewed filmmaker Jeffrey Palmer, a good creator of the feature film for this week’s Native Bidaské.

About "N. Scott Momaday: Words from a Bear"

N. Scott Momaday (Kiowa/Cherokee), one of the most prolific contemporary Native American writers, has passed away at his home in Santa Fe, New Mexico. The documentary "N. Scott Momaday: Words from a Bear" explores the life and mind of Navarro Scott Momaday, a Kiowa novelist, short-story writer, essayist, and poet who won the National Medal of Arts. Momaday's Pulitzer Prize-winning novel "House Made of Dawn" marked a breakthrough for Native American literature. The film uses original animation, historical photos, and interviews with prominent figures, including indigenous authors, actors like Robert Redford and Jeff Bridges, and Joy Harjo, the first Native American U.S. Poet Laureate, to delve into Momaday's creative core. Directed by Jeffrey Palmer, a member of the Kiowa Tribe, the documentary provides a personal exploration of Native American life in the 21st century, reflecting on Momaday's influence as a founding figure of the Native American Renaissance in art and literature. 

Momaday's work, while rooted in his heritage, also raises universal questions about origins and collective memories, offering insights into the challenges faced by Native American artists in the 20th and 21st centuries. The film premiered at the Sundance Film Festival in 2019.

About Jeffery Palmer

Jeffrey Palmer, an award-winning filmmaker and proud member of the Kiowa Tribe of Oklahoma. Renowned for his groundbreaking debut feature, "N. Scott Momaday: Words from a Bear," Palmer invites us on a mesmerizing journey into the lives of Indigenous people in twenty-first-century America. Premiered at the 2019 Sundance Film Festival and nationally aired on PBS's American Masters, the film earned an Emmy nomination in 2020, securing its place as an Outstanding Documentary or Non-Fiction Series. 

Palmer's storytelling finesse is underscored by his environmental advocacy, as evident in the Ted Turner Award-winning film. From the prestigious Bill and Melinda Gates Short Film Challenge to screenings at global venues, Palmer's cinematic brilliance has earned accolades and grants from institutions like the Sundance Institute and Ford Foundation. A member of elite industry organizations, Palmer, an associate professor at Cornell University, is currently weaving his magic on his second feature film, "Ghosts," promising another chapter in his impactful cinematic legacy.

Don't miss this insightful and engaging edition of Native Bidaské LIVE this Friday, February 2, 2024, at 12 p.m. Noon Eastern Time. Watch this episode on Native News Online's Facebook, Twitter, or YouTube channel.


Walt Bresette, Ojibwe leader and environmental hero, in Wisconsin Conservation Hall of Fame

AL GEDICKS

JANUARY 31, 2024

Sandy Lyon and Walt Bresette

 Sandy Lyon and Walt Bresette at the acid train blockade on the Bad River Ojibwe reservation. | Photo by Kathy Olson, published with permission.

Ojibwe environmental and treaty rights activist Walt Bresette will be inducted posthumously into the Wisconsin Conservation Hall of Fame (WCHF) in a virtual ceremony on April 17, 2024. Bresette will join over 100 members inducted since the Hall of Fame’s  inception, including Aldo Leopold, Nina Leopold Bradley, John Muir, Gaylord Nelson and Menominee Nation environmentalist Hilary Waukau, Sr.

Bresette (1947-1999) was a member of the Red Cliff Band of Lake Superior Ojibwe, and a long-time treaty rights and environmental activist, author, artist, storyteller, organizer and public speaker. He was an outspoken advocate for Ojibwe treaty rights who asked people to come to the spring boat landings in northern Wisconsin during the spearfishing conflict (1980s-1990s). Walt wondered why people chose to go so far away to show support for others when there were urgent calls for solidarity closer to home. Bresette said, “You don’t have to go to Nicaragua to witness, you can witness in your own backyard.”

Walt was a founder of the Witness for Non-Violence for Treaty and Rural Rights in Northern Wisconsin, modeled on the group Witness for Peace, which was active during the Central American wars (especially in the Contra-backed areas of Nicaragua). The Wisconsin witnesses documented anti-Indian harassment and violence at the boat landings. By 1992, the efforts of the witnesses and a federal court injunction against anti-Indian harassment decreased the violence at the boat landings.

Bresette was a prolific organizer who brought together Native American and rural white communities through organizations like the Midwest Treaty Network, the Upper Great Lakes Green Network and the Wisconsin Greens. He said that the fight between Natives and non-Natives over the walleye harvest diverted attention from the far more significant pollution threat to the Wisconsin fishery for both groups from proposed metallic sulfide mining. 

One of his most powerful messages was that Ojibwe treaty rights provided the greatest environmental protection against destructive metallic sulfide mining, like the Crandon and Ladysmith mining projects, in the ceded territory of the Lake Superior Ojibwe tribes. This was not because the tribes had a direct claim to minerals –—they definitely did not — but because mining threatens the environment, and a threat to the environment is a threat to Ojibwe fishing, hunting and gathering rights. Treaty rights provide the Ojibwe tribes with legal standing in federal courts to protect the habitat of fish, deer and wild rice. 

Bresette was a leader in the successful resistance to the controversial Crandon mine next to the Sokaogon Ojibwe reservation (2003) and he led the grassroots campaign to enact Wisconsin’s “Prove It First” Mining Moratorium law. The law, signed by Governor Tommy Thompson on Earth Day, 1998, prohibited the opening of a new mine in a sulfide ore body until a mining applicant could prove they had not polluted surface water or groundwater in any of their previous mines in the U.S. or Canada.

As a non-violent Ogichidaag (protector of the people), Bresette was active in the opposition to the Rio Tinto/Kennecott copper mine next to the Flambeau River near Ladysmith, Wisconsin. In 1991, the Lac Courte Oreilles Ojibwe and the Sierra Club obtained a preliminary injunction against mine construction because the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR) had failed to conduct an environmental assessment for endangered resources in the Flambeau River. Despite the restraining order, Kennecott continued construction activity at the site. 

Bresette said that the State of Wisconsin had failed to protect the interests of the Lake Superior Ojibwe and decided to take action to protect the environment.   

I witnessed Bresette climbingover a 10-foot security fence at the Flambeau mine site carrying a club once used by Black Hawk, and “counted coup” on a giant earth mover. The act of hitting the machine was a symbolic scoring of victory against one’s enemies but did no physical damage. In his trial for trespassing on mining company property,  Bresette said the mining permit was illegal because the State of Wisconsin did not consult the Lake Superior Ojibwe about their treaty rights in the fishery of the Flambeau River before it issued the mining permit. 

I interviewed Bresette for my documentary film, Anishinaabe Niijii (Friends of the First People), about the Indian and environmental resistance to the proposed Flambeau mine. Bresette and his good friend Sandy Lyon were co-founders of Anishinaabe Niijii. He said, “Someday our children are going to rise up and say, ‘Where were you when they poisoned my river?’”  His words were prescient. The mine operated from 1993 to 1997. A Flambeau River tributary that crosses part of the reclaimed project site remains polluted to the present day.

Bresette and the Ogichidaa from the Bad River Ojibwe reservation were more successful in 1996 when they blockaded trains traveling through the reservation carrying sulfuric acid to a nearby copper mine in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula. The Ogichidaa were concerned that the tracks were unsafe and that a spill from tankers would poison reservation water and the largest wild rice stand in the Great Lakes region. The blockade lasted 28 days and prevented the transport of sulfuric acid across the reservation as a federal mediator conducted talks between the Ogichidaa, the tribe and the railway. The blockade and the assertion of tribal sovereignty protected the Bad River’s sacred wild rice beds and won the support of surrounding communities.

Walt was a charismatic storyteller who was a regular keynote speaker at the many Protect the Earth festivals, organized by Sandy Lyon, on Indian reservations throughout northern Wisconsin.  His vision of a Seventh Generation Constitutional Amendment adopted the Iroquois concept that required Iroquois leaders to think about how today’s decision will affect the seventh generation into the future. The amendment promoted “the rights of the people to use and enjoy air, water, sunlight, and other renewable resources determined by the Congress to be common property, nor shall such use impair their availability for the future generations.” 

Sandy Lyon summarized Bresette’s influence eloquently in a radio tribute broadcast on Woodland Community Radio WOJB-FM on the Lac Courte Oreilles reservation: “He was like the North Star and the people followed him.”


OPB

Documentary ‘Downwind’ shows deadly consequences of nuclear testing on tribal lands

By Lillian Karabaic (OPB) and Winston Szeto (OPB)
Jan. 21, 2024
Ian Zabarte, who has black hair in a ponytail, wears a blue shirt against a desert backdrop

Western Shoshone Principal Man Ian Zabarte, who lost his family members to diseases caused by radiation exposure, says it amounts to racism against Native Americans that the U.S. government detonated more than 900 atomic bombs on his ancestors’ land in secret from 1951 to 1992.


New House Resolution Would Annul the Monroe Doctrine!

By Katherine Hoyt

Katherine Hoyt was National Co-Coordinator of the Nicaragua Network and the Alliance for Global Justice for many years before her retirement. She is now on the board of the Alliance for Global Justice.

In 1904, President Theodore Roosevelt added the Roosevelt Corollary to the Monroe Doctrine. It stated that the United States could become involved in a Latin American country’s internal affairs in cases of what the US judged as “wrongdoing” by that Latin American country. Cartoon by William Allen Rogers 1904.

On the 200th anniversary of its announcement to the US Congress by President James Monroe, Representative Nydia Velasquez (D-NY) introduced a resolution in the House of Representatives calling for the annulment of the Monroe Doctrine. This Doctrine, as Rep. Velasquez’ stated, has been used to justify American intervention in Latin American affairs throughout the policy’s history. The Doctrine, issued by President Monroe on Dec. 2, 1823, stated that any interference in the Americas by a European power would be viewed as a hostile act by the United States. In 1904, President Theodore Roosevelt added the Roosevelt Corollary, which stated that the United States could become involved in a Latin American country’s internal affairs in cases of what the US judged as “wrongdoing” by that Latin American country.

House Resolution 943 is also co-sponsored by Representatives Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) Jesus Chuy Garcia (D-IL), Delia Ramirez (D-IL), and Greg Casar (D-TX). Rep. Casar said in the press release announcing the resolution, “U.S. foreign policy has too often contributed to instability in Latin America. Instead of toppling duly-elected governments, we can support democracy, grow our economies, and reduce forced migration. Instead of sanctions that starve our neighbors, we can work together to solve the climate crisis. We can begin charting this new way forward by eliminating the outdated Monroe Doctrine.”

Click here to ask your Representative to co-sponsor HR 943 and get rid of the Monroe Doctrine!

The action alert put out by World Beyond War, says “Imagine what you think the text of this resolution probably says…. It's better than that.” And it is!

In a series of “Whereas,” the Resolution traces the history of US intervention in Latin America from the annexation of Texas and of over half of Mexican territory in the 1840s to the 2019 right-wing coup in Bolivia. The longest paragraph covers the period in the 1980s when the United States funded genocide in Guatemala, murderous paramilitary death squads in El Salvador, and the violent contras trying to overthrow the revolutionary Sandinista government of Nicaragua.

The Resolution then says, “be it resolved that it is the sense of the House of Representatives that… the Department of State should formally confirm that the Monroe Doctrine is no longer a part of United States policy toward Latin American and the Caribbean; [and] in place of the Monroe Doctrine, the Federal Government should develop a ‘New Good Neighbor’ policy, designed to foster improved relations and deepen more effective cooperation with all the countries of the hemisphere.”

The Resolution calls for a new approach to promoting development based on a respect for the integrity of the sovereign economic development plans of the region’s governments. The United States has supported many coups in Latin America and the Caribbean because US leaders found a country’s development plans to be “socialist” or in another way offensive to the US government.

And, among other measures, the Resolution calls for “terminating all unilateral economic sanctions imposed through Executive orders, and working with Congress to terminate all unilateral sanctions mandated by law, such as the Cuba embargo.” The United States has imposed sanctions on many countries around the globe. This would end those imposed by the President and mandate the President to work with Congress to eliminate those resulting from laws Congress has passed, such as the infamous NICA Act which has prevented Nicaragua from receiving loans from international financial institutions.

Another measure calls for “proceeding with the prompt declassification of all United States Government archives that relate to past coups d’état, dictatorships, and periods in the history of Latin American and Caribbean countries that are characterized by a high rate of human rights crimes perpetrated by security forces.” Declassification would enable us to learn more detail about US support for coups and attempted coups in the distant past as well as more recent ones such as the golpes that overthrew Honduran President Manuel Zelaya in 2009 and Bolivian President Evo Morales in 2019, as well as the attempted coup against Daniel Ortega in Nicaragua in 2018.

Further measures included in the Resolution promote collaboration with Latin American and Caribbean governments on a far-reaching reform of the Organization of American States and support democratic reforms to the International Monetary Fund, World Bank, Inter-American Development Bank, and other international financial institutions. These are reforms that progressives have been demanding for many years. The Resolution also calls for the creation of trust fund under the UN to support climate action in developing countries with recurrent contributions from the United States to that fund. The obligation of the rich industrialized countries who caused global warming to help the rest of the world adapt has been continually voiced by Nicaragua at world forums.

HR 943 has been sent to the House Foreign Affairs Committee, presumably to the Subcommittee on the Western Hemisphere. The members of that subcommittee are Maria Salazar (R-FL), Mark Green (R-TN), Bill Huizenga (R-MI), Waren Davidson (R-OH), Keith Self (R-TX), John James (R-MI), Ranking Minority Member Joaquin Castro (D-TX), Greg Stanton (D-AZ), Sydney Kamlager-Dove (D-CA), and Jared Moskowitz (D-FL). If your Representative sits on that subcommittee, make a special point of contacting them.

The Resolution will need additional co-sponsors in order to make any progress in the House of Representatives. Please contact your Representative asking them to co-sponsor this important Resolution. It is rare that there is a measure before Congress that we can wholeheartedly back and we should pull out all the stops to build awareness of and support for the Resolution! The World Beyond War action alert was endorsed by Code Pink and Roots Action. We will work to bring other groups to work on supporting the Resolution which would bring a major change to US Foreign Policy if it were to pass!

Click here to ask your Representative to co-sponsor HR 943 and get rid of the Monroe Doctrine!

 

Walk with our Ancestors will honor Menominee heritage

· DAN KITKOWSKI EagleHerald Senior Reporter
STEPHENSON, Mich. — Walk with our Ancestors, a peaceful awareness walk among the Menominee Indian people, will take place Saturday at Sixty Islands on the Menominee River, west of Stephenson.
The National Park Service has 60 Islands listed on The National Register of Historic Places. This site, “Anaem Omot,” which translates to “The Dog’s Belly,” is the traditional name for the Sixty Islands area. It is not far from the proposed Back Forty mine.
Persons of Menominee Indian Heritage, the Coalition to Save the Menominee River, private landowners and others invite the public to join in the walk among the ancestors of the Menominee people.
Activities begin at 7 a.m. with a sunrise ceremony followed by light snacks. Sunrise teachings — to help “deepen our connections and strengthen our work” — will follow and then opening words.
The walk begins at 11 a.m. at Tom Boerner’s residence, N9695 North River Road, Stephenson, MI 49887. A potluck feast will take place after the walk, followed by closing words.
“We are doing this walk to honor and protect our ancestral home, the water, and ancestors who have been here since time immemorial,” according to information provided by the Menominee people.
Women and girls are asked to wear long skirts, while men and boys should wear ribbon shirts or vests, or wear the best. Everyone should wear comfortable shoes for walking.
Participants are asked to bring a dish to pass for the feast. They are encouraged to bring homemade, homegrown and/or unprocessed foods.
This area in Michigan and Wisconsin features archeological remains of indigenous burial mounds, dance circles and ancient agriculture, according to a press release.
Tribal members have paid homage to this location for many, many years making offerings and wishes for good luck to the young woman who spirit visits the terrace overlooking 60 Islands. “Anaem Omot is a traditional cultural place significant to the Menominee Indian Tribe,” wrote National Park Service spokesperson Ellie Stuckrath.
Boerner said this site goes back as far as the last Ice Age. “To me this is significant because I can look in the house I live in that’s 100 years old and say, ‘wow, that’s old,’” he said. “Can you imagine going back and saying my ancestors lived in this area, they raised families, they had kids, they lived and died on this spot as far back thousands and thousands of years ago?”
He said this is significant to this area because there are so many municipalities, buildings, rivers and streets named after the Menominee people and other Native American tribes.
“The area itself has a rich heritage, that I think unless we take time to document it and remind ourselves of it, it’s forgotten on people — particularly the newer generation that tends to be able to leave the area,” he said. “They don’t realize this.”
Boerner said his 95-year-old father, Bill Boerner, who is still living and witnessed Menominee people fishing along the river, believes the Menominee people haven’t been honored as they should. “This is sort of a way to do that, to understand their lineage, their heritage,” he said.
It is feared by man that the proposed Back Forty mine would pollute the water and damage the historical sites and other properties along the river.
Boerner said dozens of people from the Coalition to Save the Menominee River are expected to attend the ceremony to show their support for the sacred rituals of the Menominee people.
Directions from Stephenson
• Go west 12.2 miles on G12 from the intersection of U.S. in Stephenson.
• Turn right on River Road.
· At the split in road to Shakey Lakes County Park stay left on River Road. From that point it is 5.3 miles north on River Road to 60 Islands on the left side of road.
For more information, people can contact [email protected]

STAND WITH STANDING ROCK!


Standing Rock Sioux and Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe

The Dakota Access Pipeline (DAPL) is a risky oil pipeline that threatens drinking water and was built without adequate environmental analysis or Tribal consultation. We currently have a critical opportunity to shut it down once and for all! 

Between now and November 13th, the Army Corps of Engineers has a comment period. On November 1 & 2nd there are public hearings in Bismarck, ND. We need you to join us to Stand with Standing Rock again and call on the Biden Administration to shut down DAPL.

The Standing Rock Sioux and Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe and grassroots water protectors have led the resistance against the dirty Dakota Access Pipeline (DAPL) since the beginning. Now, thanks to their continued resistance and leadership, thousands of us have a chance to go on the record with our support and submit official public comments with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers against this dirty oil pipeline.

Following mass Indigenous-led protests and international outcries against the pipeline in 2016 and 2017, the Obama Administration correctly recognized the Corps’ obligation to evaluate the project in an environmental impact statement (EIS) process before approval. Soon after taking office, the Trump Administration reversed course, ignored the law, and pushed the project forward. 

Now, following a 2021 court order, the Army Corps is taking public comments on its recently released Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) on the pipeline -- providing us with an important opportunity to continue to Stand with Standing Rock and demand the shutdown of a pipeline that never should have been built to begin with.

Submit your official written comment to the Army Corps of Engineers and make sure you personalize it -- tell them why it’s time to shut down the Dakota Access Pipeline once and for all!

Comments are due by 11:59pm EST on Monday, November 13

*Please draft your own original comments based on the talking points below and other resources linked above. They can be short and heartfelt, but please do not just copy and paste language from this toolkit – duplicate comments will be counted by the Army Corps as a signal comment, so be sure to make it your own. 

Public comments can be sent to USACE by US Postal Service or Emailed with subject line: “Comments on the DAPL DEIS” to: [email protected] or at the following address:

Attn: Brent Cossette

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

CENWO-ODT-N

1616 Capitol Avenue

Omaha, NE 68102

DON'T CUT AND PASTE!

For more information: https://www.nwo.usace.army.mil/Missions/Dam-and-Lake-Projects/Oil-and-Gas-Development/Dakota-Access-Pipeline/

The Dakota Access Pipeline has been operating for several years but is still being contested by the Standing Rock Sioux and Cheyenne River Sioux Tribes. DAPL faced immense international opposition during construction, with tens of thousands of people joining in resistance on the ground. This new Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) was ordered by the Courts and is as a result of the Cheyenne River Tribe’s continuing legal fight against the project.

In 2016, communities across the world protested in solidarity with the Standing Rock Sioux and Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe against the Dakota Access Pipeline (DAPL) and the threat it posed to the Tribes' drinking water supply. 

In 2017, the Obama Administration correctly recognized the Corps’ obligation to evaluate DAPL in an EIS before approval. Trump reversed course, ignored the law, and quickly pushed the project through before the courts were able to confirm that an EIS was required. 

Just a couple years later, DAPL expanded capacity from 570,000 barrels/day (one of the biggest pipelines in North Dakota) to 1.1 million barrels per day (one of the biggest pipeline capacities in the whole country). In 2021, the D.C. Circuit Court affirmed the Corps violated environmental protection laws due to a lack of federal environmental review for DAPL, revoked the easement, and ordered the Corps to complete an EIS -- but fell short of stopping the flow of oil through the pipeline. 

Throughout this fight water protectors have been resisting this risky pipeline and all of the harm that comes with it running through their communities. From destroying sacred sites, putting drinking water at risk, increasing the problem of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Relatives (MMIR) that comes with fossil fuel project construction, and exacerbating climate change, DAPL has already caused real harm and should be shut down.


Clearwater County jury finds 68-year-old 'water protector' guilty in misdemeanor trial

 Jill Ferguson stands in front of the Clearwater County Courthouse on Wednesday, Aug. 30, 2023, while the jury deliberates its verdict.

 

 https://www.kaxe.org/local-news/2023-08-31/clearwater-county-jury-finds-68-year-old-water-protector-guilty-in-misdemeanor-trial?fbclid=IwAR2CbOV_kDWd5XkHjnzU-9Nl9pt4dQmVHW3AGOaboaX7MlPQNK9RAl0vSyE

While receiving no jail time, the trial of Jill Ferguson hinged on her resisting arrest during a July 29, 2021, incident. Ferguson maintains she acted in defense of the Mississippi River

BAGLEY — A Clearwater County jury found a 68-year-old Milwaukee woman guilty of a misdemeanor obstruction charge following a three-day trial on Wednesday, Aug. 30.

Jill Ferguson was arrested on July 29, 2021, after refusing to comply with officers’ demands to clear an area near crews’ dewatering equipment during the construction of Enbridge’s Line 3 replacement project.

Ferguson, according to the criminal complaint, was among a group of people near the Mississippi River near a caged water pump and advised officers she would not leave the area unless forced to do so.


Leonard Peltier is a Native American human rights activist and member of the American Indian Movement (AIM). In 1977, he was wrongfully convicted of the murders of two FBI agents during a confrontation at the Pine Ridge Reservation in South Dakota. His trial was marked by controversy, with allegations of misconduct and withheld evidence.
Leonard Peltier has been imprisoned for nearly 50 years, including years spent in solitary confinement, serving two life sentences for murder despite critical concerns over the fairness of his trial. He has always maintained his innocence.
He is 78 years old, in declining health and suffers from a number of serious life-threatening illnesses, including diabetes and an abdominal aortic aneurism and other comorbidities. His lawyers have submitted a new petition for clemency.
President Biden must grant Leonard Peltier clemency on humanitarian grounds and as a matter of justice.
We are calling on the authorities and President Joe Biden to grant clemency to Native American Elder Leonard Peltier. #FreeLeonardPeltier
https://www.facebook.com/search/top?q=leonard%20peltier

TAKE ACTION >>> https://act.amnestyusa.org/page/96017/action/1...

Indigenous Trade Unionists From Around the World Call for More Inclusion and Solidarity: “We Are Not Just There To Sing the Songs and Do the Opening Prayer”

José Álvarez Díaz
August 9, 2023
Equal Times
More than 476 million people worldwide (6.2 per cent of humanity) belong to Indigenous peoples, most of whom live alongside the societies that colonised their ancient lands hundreds of years ago. In the 21st century, after a long journey during which they were not always able to survive colonial oppression without losing their identity, language or part of their culture, Indigenous peoples have won significant gains in various regions of the world but they continue to face challenges such as discrimination and limited opportunities, making it very difficult for them to enjoy fair labour market integration. Four out of five Indigenous workers earn a living from informal employment, and the remainder most often work in highly precarious sectors, without any form of social protection, where they are exposed to all kinds of rights abuses.
READ MORE

Where Sustaining the Forest Also Sustains a Tribal Economy

The Wolf River flowing through the Menominee Indian Reservation in Wisconsin.
PHOTO BY CHRIS FORD VIA FLICKR
The Menominee Tribe of Wisconsin’s successful logging operation follows one rule: Let the healthy trees keep growing.
 Why you can trust us

BY FRED PEARCE
 8 MIN READ
AUG 11, 2023

Mike Lohrengel looks up in awe at trees he has known for 30 years. “This is one of the most beautiful places I know. This forest has it all: the most species, the most diversity. Many trees I know individually. Look at this one behind us. It’s got a split way up there. I’ll never forget that tree till I die.”

It is a love affair, for sure. But Lohrengel is no tree hugger, out to preserve a special, pristine place. He is a timber harvest administrator, overseeing logging in one of the most remarkable working forests in the United States—nearly a quarter-million acres of trees that occupy almost the entire Menominee Indian Reservation in northern Wisconsin.

“The forest looks pristine,” he says, as a flurry of snow falls through the open canopy. “These big maples and basswoods are around 150 years old. But we have been logging here for over a century, and we still have more trees than when we started.” In June, the tribe’s forestry officials began exploring the potential for selling the carbon accumulating in the forest on the U.S.’s growing market for carbon-offset credits.

There are probably more than a billion trees today in the Menominee forest, which is an hour’s drive west of Lake Michigan. We were there in late February, the day after the biggest snowstorm of the winter. We were standing near the Menominee’s sawmill in Neopit village, from where trucks move the lumber across America to make everything from basketball courts to domestic furniture and handcrafted toys. But even close to the mill, big healthy trees with the highest potential price tag get to grow old.

The trick, says Lohrengel, is husbandry for the long term. “We come in every 15 years, take out the weak trees, the sick trees, and the ones that are dying, but leave the healthy stock to grow some more and reproduce,” he says. “We don’t plant anything. This is all natural regeneration, and the way we do it the forest just gets better and better.”

Lohrengel is not a Menominee tribal member. He is the son of a pulp-mill worker who has been devoted to the tribe’s harvesting philosophy since first working on the reservation inventorying the trees in 1990. Most U.S. foresters, he says, are trained to cut the best trees and leave the sick ones behind. The result is a forest with deteriorating genetic stock. But the Menominee are “doing the opposite, and making the forest healthier.”

“We make our decisions based on what’s best for the forest,” says Lohrengel’s boss, the Menominee’s veteran head forester Ron Waukau. “Our logging schedules and management are purely for the forest. I am really humbled to be able to work like that. The sawmill knows what it will get and sells accordingly.”

For the Menominee, says head silviculturist Tony Waupochick, it is not just a matter of maintaining the volume of timber. “We are also managing the forest to maintain its diversity and integrity, and to keep it healthy for wildlife.”

The Menominee adopted their enlightened approach soon after the creation of the reservation in 1854. It has worked spectacularly well, says Patrick McBride, sales director of the Pennsylvania-based lumber company MacDonald & Owen, which buys most of the output from the Menominee sawmill. In almost 170 years, the tribe has harvested nearly twice the forest’s former volume of timber, yet it still has 40% more standing wood than when they started. “And by leaving the best trees, the old and sick lumber they harvest is now better than the best from most everyone else,” says McBride, who pays a premium price for it.

The 235,000-acre Menominee reservation is 93% forested, and visible from space as a dark green block of trees.

Professional U.S. foresters today like to say that America’s shift from blindly clear-cutting trees to managing them more sustainably began in the 1890s, with the founding of the Biltmore Forest School in North Carolina, followed in 1900 by the founding of the Yale Forest School. But the Menominee were decades ahead of them, argues Michael Dockry, who researches American Indian and Indigenous natural resource management at the University of Minnesota. In the mid-19th century, he writes, they already practiced “a new form of forest management that stood in stark contrast to the cut-and-run harvesting occurring through the rest of Wisconsin and the United States.” It was “the first sustained-yield forest management system in the country.”

The 235,000-acre Menominee reservation is today 93% forested and famously visible from space as a dark-green block of maple and aspen, birch and hemlock, ash and basswood, red oak and white pine, surrounded by dairy pastures long since cleared of trees by immigrant farmers. Some trees are more than 200 years old and more than 200 feet high. Around a quarter are left unharvested, mostly in swamp areas, at sacred sites, and in important wildlife refuges, says Waukau. Foresters come from across the world to walk the reservation with him and see how the Menominee harvest the rest. “Basically, we are taking tribal knowledge and blending it with today’s ecological science.”

An inspector grades lumber at the Menominee sawmill, with visitors on tour in the background. Photo courtesy of Nels Huse

The Menominee forest was among the first to be certified by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC), after its formation in 1993. That recognition of sustainability was a no-brainer, say FSC insiders. The Menominee’s crews currently cut only around a third as much timber as the forest grows each year—8 or 9 million board-feet each year, compared to growth of around 24 million acre-feet.

A detailed study by Nicholas Reo of Dartmouth College and Donald Waller of the University of Wisconsin, Madison in 2018 found that, after more than a century of logging, the Menominee forest was “more mature, with higher tree volume, higher rates of tree regeneration, more plant diversity and fewer invasive species than nearby nontribal forest lands.” The FSC rates the majority of the forest as of “high conservation value” with large expanses where “naturally occurring species exist in natural patterns.”

The Menominee’s forestry approach was the brainchild of the tribe’s revered 19th-century chief, Oshkosh. After negotiating the 1854 treaty that secured the reservation for his people, he codified how they should harvest its forest. “Start with the rising sun and work towards the setting sun, but take only the mature trees, the sick trees, and the trees that have fallen,” he said. “When your reach the end of the reservation, turn and cut from the setting sun to the rising sun, and the trees will last forever.” His words are inscribed on a plaque at the entrance to the tribe’s forestry offices.

Menominee forestry practices are underpinned by their cultural and spiritual traditions, conveyed by their ancient language.

Logging techniques have changed since Oshkosh’s day. Handsaws and horse-drawn skids have been replaced by chainsaws and heavy dragging equipment. In an hour, a drone can see what would have taken human eyes many weeks. But Oshkosh’s philosophy persists, says McKaylee Duquain, who runs today’s forest inventory.

Among the mostly older male Menominee foresters, Duquain stands out as young, female, and tech-savvy. After studying conservation sciences at the University of Minnesota, she returned to the reservation three years ago to take charge of the logging schedule. “I decide what areas are going to be cut next, figure out how much is in there, whether the trees are mature enough, and so on,” she says.

Each year, her team surveys thousands of acres of the forest, often delving deep into its history, comparing today’s aerial images with maps hand-drawn on acetate sheets by predecessors who paced out the land, compass in hand. But Duquain and her colleagues also put on their boots to identify and mark individual sick or old trees for harvesting, and to ensure that those with a diameter less than 10 inches are spared. Only then do Menominee and other local contractors bring in their chainsaws—mostly in winter when the ground is frozen hard, so removing the logs does not damage the ground.

Besides this continuous cycle of selective forest thinning, some small areas are clear-cut. This is to help the growth of species such as oak that require plenty of sunlight, says Duquain’s boss, Waukau. Fire is another important tool, he says, burning undergrowth and logging leftovers at the start of the summer to remove material that could fuel major fires later in the season.

The Menominee fire team spends as much time starting fires as stopping them, says Curtis Wayka, who runs the burning program. In quiet times, the team travels the U.S. sharing their expertise. That expertise has a long heritage, says Waukau. “Our ancestors understood and used fire well. We are going back to that.”

Many Menominee forestry practices are underpinned by their cultural and spiritual traditions, often conveyed by their ancient language, which is now being revived in the tribal school. The tribe’s creation story puts its roughly 9,000 members into five clans, each named after animals of the forest: bear, wolf, moose, crane, and eagle, all of which are revered and protected. Don Reiter, the reservation wildlife manager, identified around 25 wolves in the reservation last winter, in five packs. He estimates there could be as many as 250 black bears.

The reservation is estimated to be making a net capture of more than 30,000 tons of carbon dioxide from the air annually.

Many Menominee craft traditions use materials from their forest: black ash for basketry, basswood for wigwams and rope, and birch for canoes. “The ironwood tree is too strong for our mill to utilize, but we have always carved it,” says Joey Awonohopay, director of the Menominee Language and Culture Commission, who identifies as a member of the bear clan. Traditionally, it made warriors’ clubs. The tapping of maple trees for their syrup each spring remains hugely popular, and some people still gather medicinal plants such as bitterroot and ginseng.

But it is lumber sales that dominate the Menominee economy, accounting for around half the reservation’s economic activity. The business is run by Menominee Tribal Enterprises (MTE), a body elected by the tribe to operate commercially but sustainably. Its newly elected president, Michael Skenadore, says he faces some pressing issues to ensure its future viability. The sawmill, which was erected in 1908 and last refitted in the 1980s, needs heavy investment. And it is increasingly difficult to find young people willing to work as loggers in the forest during the long cold winters. Many prefer employment in the reservation’s other major concern: the casino.

But Skenadore has an eye to the future. He has begun investigating the potential to profit from selling carbon credits generated by the forest’s accumulating timber. “Along with a number of tribes from all over the country, we are exploring our options,” he says. According to industry calculators, the reservation could currently be making a net capture of more than 30,000 tons of carbon dioxide from the air each year.

The Menominee Tribal Enterprises sawmill. Photo courtesy of Menominee Tribal Enterprises

Will the forest continue to thrive? However good the management, there are growing environmental threats. Changing climate is bringing more windstorms, says Lohrengel. The most recent blast, in June 2022, consigned 12 million board-feet—more than a year’s typical harvest—to the forest floor in 20 minutes. The foresters were out the following day flying drones to identify the damaged areas, and for the next nine months abandoned their logging schedules to concentrate on salvaging the downed timber.

Invasive pests can be a menace, too. The emerald ash borer, an Asian insect that has spread to 36 states since its arrival in the U.S. in 2002, finally entered the reservation last fall. “We were the last place in Wisconsin to get it,” says Waukau. He fears the worst. “It’s hard to imagine the ash not being in our forest, but it may be inevitable.” Despite such threats, he believes the large, biodiverse, and sustainably managed forest he oversees is more resilient than most. “Maybe in 30 or 40 years we will have lost some species, but I fully expect the forest will be thriving.”

Back in the forest, Lohrengel points to a clutch of tiny maple saplings reaching up to light streaming through the canopy after recent felling. “They look small now,” he says. “But future generations will be marveling at how big they become.”

This story was originally published in Yale E360 and is reprinted here with permission. Fred Pearce traveled to the Menominee Indian Reservation with the support of the American Hardwood Export Council.


Indigenous Peoples Movement

IPM Responds to Gross Violation of Human Rights at Thacker Pass

https://indigenouspeoplesmovement.org/

June 25, 2023

The Indigenous Peoples Movement is an organization dedicated to protecting the rights, traditions, and sacred lands of Indigenous peoples. We are deeply disturbed by the recent events at Thacker Pass, Nevada, which have seen a gross violation of human rights, destruction of sacred sites, and a total disregard for the voice of our people.

Thacker Pass, or Peehee Mu’huh in the Paiute language, is a site of immense cultural and spiritual significance to the Paiute and Shoshone peoples. It has been a center for traditional ceremonies, medicines, tools, and food supply for thousands of years. Moreover, it is the site of two tragic massacres of our people, the first being an intertribal conflict and the second a horrendous attack by the U.S. Cavalry in 1865. The remains of our massacred ancestors have remained unidentified and unburied since 1865, and now face further indignity as they are bulldozed and crushed for the mineral known as “the new white gold”. 

The Ox Sam Indigenous Women’s Camp, named after a survivor of the 1865 Thacker Pass Massacre, has been the base camp for resistance against the establishment of the largest open-pit lithium mine in North America. The camp was recently raided by law enforcement officials on behalf of Lithium Nevada Corporation. This action led to the destruction of two ceremonial tipi lodges, confiscation and mishandling of ceremonial instruments and objects, the extinguishing of a sacred fire, and an arrest without warning of one of our water protectors, a young Diné woman, who was then subjected to frightening and inhumane conditions.

The Bureau of Land Management (BLM), despite persistent legal challenges from the Reno-Sparks Indian Colony, Summit Lake Paiute Tribe, and Burns Paiute Tribe, has continued to permit this exploitation of Thacker Pass, overlooking the area’s sacred significance to regional Tribal Nations.

As the Indigenous Peoples Movement, we unequivocally condemn these actions and demand the immediate cessation of activities at Thacker Pass. We insist upon the respect for our right to peaceful protest and demand the release of our confiscated ceremonial objects, the preservation of our sacred sites, and the upholding of our religious freedom rights. We also call for the immediate release of the arrested Diné woman and an investigation into her mistreatment.

We implore you to listen to our plea and join us in protecting the sacred lands of Indigenous peoples, their rights, and their traditions. We must ensure that such inhumane actions and gross violations of human rights do not go unnoticed and unaddressed.

Thank you for your attention to this matter. We look forward to your support and action.

 

International Leonard Peltier Defense Committee

Today, June 26, is Leonard Peltier Day in Oglala S D. Internationally recognizes as a political prisoner, he has been unjustly incarcerated for 17,307 days. The International Leonard Peltier Defense Committee is asking for:

  1. A transfer to a medium security prison;
  2. A congressional investigation into the FBI’s misconduct in Indian Country, against the American Indian Movement and in the case of Leonard Peltier;
  3. An Executive Review by the Attorney General;
  4. An award of Executive Clemency
  5. The release of tens of thousands of related case documents.

Enbridge's proposed pipeline expansion of Line 5, upstream of the Bad River Watershed in Northern Wisconsin, would impact 186 waterways. This means that a pipeline rupture could contaminate the Copper Falls State Park, Kakagon Sloughs, and the Bad River Reservation.  The Kakagon Sloughs provide essential habitat for large areas of wild rice.
https://ganawendannibi.org/resources/?fbclid=IwAR2I8HH5-g0v_1u68Xe8Z0xr08R4bajoS76ceHZdaLckz_PdwTE-Aku6KUY/
Stop Enbridge’s Line 5
The Line 5 Pipeline threatens Tribal land, Treaty Rights in the ceded territory, the Great Lakes, and the climate. The pipeline, which is long past its lifespan, is currently pumping tar sands oil …
ganawendannibi.org

Image

https://www.wecaninternational.org/stop-line-5?fbclid=IwAR0cppHY4pGZqijb_4p_EI3PsUmHLcsNEp_qs_jVR_RwRmAl9OtB7UmmmIM

Indigenous leaders urge Biden to shut down Line 5 pipeline due to ‘imminent’ threat

BY: JON KING - MAY 27, 2023

 “Heart of the Turtle” international Indigenous gathering in opposition to oil pipelines, Mackinaw City, May 14, 2022 | Laina G. Stebbins

Leaders from the Indigenous Women’s Treaty Alliance submitted a letter Thursday to the Biden administration with an emergency request to decommission the Line 5 pipeline due to imminent threats of oil spills impacting the Bad River Watershed and the Great Lakes. 

The controversial 70-year-old pipeline, operated by Canadian oil company Enbridge, flows crude oil from the Bad River Watershed in northern Wisconsin to the Upper Peninsula. From there it flows through the Straits of Mackinac to the Lower Peninsula of Michigan, and then to refineries in Sarnia, Ontario, and Detroit.

 

“We call on you to immediately revoke the Presidential Permit for Canada’s deteriorating Enbridge Line 5 pipeline before environmental calamity strikes with oil spills into the Great Lakes,” states the letter. “At the Bad River Reservation, recent flooding has eroded one riverbank to within 11 feet or less of Line 5’s centerline, creating an immediate threat. This is a nearly 70-year-old pipeline running almost two decades past its engineered lifespan.”

The letter follows an emergency filing earlier this month by the Bad River Band of the Lake Superior Chippewa in Wisconsin seeking to close the Line 5 pipeline after extensive flooding in the area. However, U.S. District Judge William Conley rejected the request, saying the pipeline did not present an imminent danger.

Enbridge officials took that ruling to bolster their case that Line 5 continues to operate safely across the Bad River Reservation. 

“In fact, Line 5 has never had a release on the Reservation,” spokesman Ryan Duffy told the Michigan Advance, while noting “that the judge said moving forward with erosion mitigation projects is critically important and multiple projects are before the Band for approval. The company needs the Band’s approval to move forward, but to date the Band has not approved any of Enbridge’s erosion control measures nor given a time frame for when they may allow this work. We stand ready to work with the Bad River Band on projects that will prevent any future erosion, that will protect the waters of the Bad River and Line 5 pipeline.”

However, the Alliance pointed to a report by the National Wildlife Federation that stated the inland sections of Line 5 have leaked at least 33 times since 1968, discharging more than 1.1 million gallons of oil.

“Independent monitoring shows the underwater section of Line 5, which transitions from a single 30-inch pipeline inland to two 20-inch pipelines in the open waters of the Great Lakes, is no longer safe in the unique and fragile environment of the Straits,” states the federation’s report.

That analysis is alarming for Indigenous leaders like Jannan J. Cornstalk, Citizen of Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians, and Director of the Water is Life Festival.

“Our very lifeways and cultures hang in the balance as Line 5 continues to operate illegally in Indigenous territories and water,” she said. “Allowing Line 5 to continue to operate is cultural genocide, and the Biden Administration must listen and shut down Line 5. That water is our relative, and we will do whatever it takes to protect our water, our sacred relative.”


FREE LEONARD PELTIER!

Norman Guberman

OPEN LETTER TO PRESIDENT BIDEN
Dear President Biden:
Please grant clemency to Leonard Peltier. Leonard — an Ojibwe and Lakota man — is a survivor of the notorious Indian boarding school system. He deserves clemency after being imprisoned for nearly half a century for a crime he may well not have committed.
It’s well documented that prosecutors and federal agents repressed exonerating evidence of his possible innocence, presented questionable testimony, and misled the jury. Any one of these violations should've normally been sufficient to obtain a new trial or a grant of clemency.
Many individuals originally connected with his case after reviewing the evidence have changed their minds and now question his original conviction. He’s also the longest held political prisoner in the United States. Moreover, he’s sick and elderly now and there exists no real reason to further hold him. Normally these considerations should make him eligible for clemency.
Locked away in federal prison since 1976, Leonard Peltier is now 78 years old. He has recently survived COVID while simultaneously dealing with a number of other serious health conditions. Revenge seems to be the only apparent reason that he’s not being granted an immediate executive clemency to live out his remaining days freely with family and friends.
It’s well-known and documented that the FBI still holds a vendetta against Mr. Peltier and strongly opposes his release. Mr. President, your hiring of Deb Haaland as the U.S. Secretary of the Interior — the first Native American Cabinet secretary — has demonstrated your concern to address the United States’ legacy of Native American suppression. In this new and emerging era, this egregious case presents a golden opportunity to fully demonstrate your care and respect for Indigenous communities.
The entire world is looking to you to right this enormous wrong: Nobel Peace Prize winners Bishop Desmond Tutu, Nelson Mandela, and Rigoberta Menchú; former Chief Judge of Tennessee’s U.S. District Court, Kevin Sharp; Sens. Brian Schatz (D-HI) and Patrick Leahy (D-VT); Rep. Raúl Grijalva (D-AZ); the Leonard Peltier Defense Committee; the Lakota People’s Law Project; Amnesty International; the 14th Dalai Lama; and James Reynolds, chief prosecutor who originally put Leonard behind bars all respectfully request his release
Please show mercy & grant clemency to Leonard Peltier. Give this decent and deserving old man the justice and liberty he deserves after all these decades.
Sincerely,

 


Communities United by
                                            Water Reject Line5

Bad River Band’s Filing for Emergency Closure Necessary to Protect Great Lakes from Dangerous Line 5 Pipeline

Barbara With — May 10, 2023

 May 10, 2023 Elizabeth Ward, [email protected]

MADISON, Wis. (May 10, 2023) — The Bad River Band’s emergency filing seeking to close Enbridge Energy’s dangerous Line 5 pipeline will help protect the Tribe from a catastrophic oil spill as well as the people and wildlife who depend upon the Great Lakes. The filing, filed in a U.S. District Court, highlights how the pipeline is at risk for exposure, with some estimates showing only 11 feet of protective soil underneath or five feet of soil covering on top. A breach of the pipeline could destroy local waters, harm wildlife, and create a public health crisis in the area. The Bad River feeds directly into Lake Superior; a rupture would mean contamination throughout the Great Lakes.

In October 2022, the Bad River Band’s experts testified at trial that spring flooding would render Line 5 inaccessible, cause damage to the supporting soil underneath the Line, or even expose the pipeline to river water flow. Enbridge asserted during the trial that this was a worst-case scenario, unlikely to happen at all, much less in the near future. However, seven months later, Tribal experts have drone footage* and concrete evidence that the exact scenario they laid out is taking place. The area where the pipeline is dangerously exposed became inaccessible — even by boat — because of flooding, rendering potential safeguards useless.

A growing number of residents, Indigenous Nations, lawmakers, businesses, and advocacy organizations  in the Great Lakes region are working to shut down Line 5, which is one rupture away from threatening a significant part of the Great Lakes, which constitute 20 percent of the world’s surface freshwater.

Enbridge has been operating its Line 5 pipeline on Bad River Band sovereign land since 1953 and has been in active and known trespass since 2013.

“Enbridge insisted that it would be years before we would see this kind of erosion. Yet, here we are facing an imminent catastrophe,” said Beth Wallace, freshwater campaigns manager for the National Wildlife Federation. “Not only is Enbridge knowingly trespassing on sovereign territory, but they appear to be gambling with an entire ecosystem to continue to pocket millions a day.” 

“Line 5 needs to be shut down. Every rainfall or snow melt brings us closer to a disaster.  Lake Superior and the Bad River watershed are critical to the life and health of the region. We can’t allow Enbridge to continue to trespass on sovereign territory while risking our water, wetlands, and climate,” said Elizabeth Ward, Sierra Club Wisconsin director. 

“Freshwater is the lifeblood of the Great Lakes region,” said Ashley Rudzinski, climate and environment program director for Groundwork Center for Resilient Communities, “Enbridge’s continued operation of Line 5 represents a direct affront to tribal sovereignty and potential catastrophe for the Bad River and the world’s second largest lake, Lake Superior. With rising floodwaters inching ever closer to the over 70-year old pipeline, we need all decision makers, including President Biden, to act with the urgency demanded by this grave situation.”

“Enbridge has proven itself more than willing to put the Great Lakes at risk to keep the oil and profits flowing.  Let’s hope the Bad River Band’s effort to convince the court to stop this imminent danger is successful,” said Scott Strand, senior attorney at the Environmental Law & Policy Center.

“The ecological, spiritual, cultural, and economic importance of Lake Superior and the Great Lakes cannot be overunderstated,” said Michelle Woodhouse, water program manager at Environmental Defence. “A rupture from Line 5 into the Mashkiiziibii (Bad River) watershed would be devastating to the Anishinaabeg and Lake Superior communities on both sides of the Canadian and U.S. border. The Great Lakes hold 84 per cent of North America’s fresh water. We do not need Line 5 to meet our energy needs. Canada must stop obstructing efforts to shut down the Line 5 pipeline.”

“We are extremely alarmed to see the shrinking distance between Line 5, which is operating in trespass of the Bad River Band, and the raging river current,” said Managing Attorney Debbie Chizewer for Earthjustice, which represents the Band on some Line 5 issues. “If government officials don’t use their power to shut down Line 5, this disaster will be on their hands.”

“As extreme weather events become more frequent and intense with climate change, we need to consider rising floodwaters as an imminent threat to the aging crude oil pipeline,and shut down Line 5 now to avert disastrous impacts on the Bad River, Lake Superior, and our freshwater,” ssaid Denise Keele, director of the Michigan Climate Action Network., and shut down Line 5 now to avert disastrous impacts on the Bad River, Lake Superior, and our freshwater.

“As an organization located in Lake Superior, on Moningwaune’akanig Minis, Madeline Island, the sacred center of the Anishinaabe, Communities United By Water adds our voices to demand that someone shut down this pipeline immediately. We have watched the banks of the Bad River eroding for years. How much longer do we wait to shut it down? Wisconsin pipeline safety is supported by the Public Service Commission. Wisconsin Emergency Response Plan has contingencies for fuel shortages but not fuel spills. Shut it down now!” Barbara with Communities United by Water.

“This serious threat to the Bad River and Lake Superior showcases corporate culture placing profit above people’s livelihoods and the environment. Lake Effect Surf Shop stands behind the Tribe in defending their sacred lands and way of life against this reckless corporation. Continued operation of Line 5 is nothing more than bad business and an accident waiting to happen,” said Jacob Bressette, owner of Lake Effect Surf Shop, Great Lakes Business Network, and Bad River Band member.

“An oil spill from the Line 5 pipeline into the Bad River would be an utter disaster for the health of all people, fish, and wildlife that depend on clean water in the region,” said Bentley Johnson, federal government affairs director for the Michigan League of Conservation Voters. “The people of the Bad River Band have sounded the alarm about the threat of erosion in this area for years, yet Enbridge continues to prioritize profits over people by refusing to take necessary action to eliminate the threat. Decision makers at all levels should be alarmed and take immediate steps to shut down Line 5 and create an orderly, planned energy transition for the Great Lakes region away from Line 5.

Filing 1 Filing 2 Filing 3

View original post

Communities United by
                                            Water Reject Line5

Communities United By Water, PO BOX 153, La Pointe, United States

Tribes Host Prayer Ceremony Near White House Urging Biden to Reverse Resolution Copper Mine

  • Yahoo News
a group of people holding signs

(Photo courtesy of Apache Stronghold and Steve Pavey)

BY DARREN THOMPSON APRIL 27, 2023

WASHINGTON— Tribal and congressional leaders joined the San Carlos Apache Tribe on Wednesday, April 26, in a prayer ceremony and press conference denouncing Arizona’s Resolution Copper Mine project. 

 The event, dubbed “Prayer to Save Oak Flat,” was hosted across the street from the White House in Lafayette Square Park. 

“The Biden Administration is poised to give sacred Apache land in eastern Arizona to foreign mining companies with close financial ties to the Chinese government to construct an unnecessary copper mine that will destroy Oak Flat,” said San Carlos Apache Tribe Chairman Terry Rambler in a statement. “Destroying Oak Flat would be a major human rights violation. Tribes across the country vehemently oppose this assault on tribal sovereignty and Native American religious freedom.”  

Resolution Copper hopes to build a copper mine near a place the Apache and other tribes consider sacred, a ceremonial ground called Chí’chil Biłdagoteel, or “Oak Flat,” in Arizona’s Tonto National Forest. Because the mine is on federal lands, the permitting process is overseen by the U.S. Forest Service. Federal legislation was passed in 2014 that paved the way for a land swap between Resolution Copper and the U.S Forest Service, where Resolution Copper would exchange 5,429 acres of Arizona land it owns in exchange for 2,422 acres of federal land above a massive copper deposit. 

The value of the mine is estimated at $64 billion, with 1.787 billion metric tonnes of copper with an average grade of 1.5% copper over the next 60 years. The company says the mine’s life will provide thousands of direct and indirect jobs and will supply nearly 25% of the domestic demand for copper. 

In the final days of the Trump Administration, the U.S. Forest Service published the project's final environmental impact statement (FEIS) on January 15, 2021. However, president Biden halted the FEIS on March 1, 2021, saying the project needed more time to consult with Indian Tribes. 

 “We want the EIS redone because the EIS the Trump Administration rushed to publish didn’t have all the negative impacts the Tribe and other organizations came up with,” San Carlos Apache Chairman Terry Rambler told Native News Online. “It wasn’t fair the way they did.”

Rambler said the tribe and allies drafted a memorandum of understanding they wanted to enter with the USDA to ensure a fair consultation process. 

Because the MOU wasn’t signed, Rambler disagrees that consultation was officially done. As a result, The Apache Stronghold — a nonprofit advocacy group led by Rambler — filed a lawsuit on January 21, 2021, against the project.

In the lawsuit, the Apache Stronghold states, “the Apaches view Oak Flat as a ‘direct corridor’ to the Creator’s spirit.” They also argued that the land exchange violates their First Amendment rights and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, where “government should not substantially burden religious exercise without compelling justification.”  

The 9th Circuit Court decided in early 2022 that Resolution Copper could proceed with operations while the lawsuit is pending in court. Last November, the court announced that it would rehear Apache Stronghold v. United States “en banc” in front of a full panel of 11 judges. The court requested the en banc hearing to rehear the case, and is extremely rare, Apache Stronghold’s legal counsel Becket Law told Native News Online last fall. A call to rehear a case happens in less than 0.5 percent of cases the court hears.

Oak Flat is listed on the National Historic Register of Historic Places as a Traditional Cultural Property. It has been protected from mining by Congress for more than 60 years. Last week, leaders at the United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues (UNPFII) acknowledged and called the Resolution Copper project a human rights violation and said the project will destroy an entire way of life for the Apache people.  

U.S. Rep. Raul Grijalva, D-Ariz., joined Apache leaders with other congressional representatives and Tribal leaders from Oklahoma and North Carolina, and the president of the Inter Tribal Association of Arizona. 

Together, they hope President Biden will stop the mine from proceeding.

More Stories Like This

San Carlos Apache take copper mine fight to United Nations
Native American Attorney and Activist Tara Houska Honored with $100,000 Rose-Walters Prize for Global Environmental Activism
Yellowstone Bison See Deadliest Season Since 2008
Scramble for clean energy metals confronted by calls to respect Indigenous rights
Free Newsletter
About The Author
Darren Thompson
Darren Thompson (Lac du Flambeau Ojibwe) is a staff reporter for Native News Online who is based in the Twin Cities of Minnesota. Thompson has reported on political unrest, tribal sovereignty, and Indigenous issues for the Aboriginal Peoples Television Network, Indian Country Today, Native News Online, Powwows.com and Unicorn Riot. He has contributed to the New York Times, the Washington Post, and Voice of America on various Indigenous issues in international conversation. He has a bachelor’s degree in Criminology & Law Studies from Marquette University in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

International week of action to defend El Salvador´s mining ban and demand the release of the five Water Defenders of Santa Marta

As social organizations in El Salvador recently celebrated the sixth anniversary of the historic mining prohibition, approved unanimously by the Legislative Assembly in 2017, there are signs that the government of President Nayib Bukele is creating conditions to overturn the law.

Despite the president’s popularity, mostly due to his hard-line approach to gangs and crime, the Salvadoran economy is failing and the government is in desperate need to attract foreign investment. In 2021, Salvadoran environmental organizations denounced that the government had joined the Intergovernmental Forum on Mining, a multilateral NGO that promotes “sustainable” mining, and shortly after, a law was passed to create a Directorate of Energy Mines and Hydrocarbons. Community leaders in Cabañas have also denounced the presence of employees of mining companies offering long-term leases on land located in areas of mining interest.

On January 11, Salvadoran police arrested 5 Water Defenders from Santa Marta in Cabañas, including Antonio Pacheco, the director of the Salvadoran Economic and Social Development Association (ADES), who was a key leader in the fight against mining for more than 12 years and had recently been sounding the alarm over Bukele’s attempts to re-open the door to multinational mining companies.

Despite the lack of evidence, the Water Defenders were quickly sentenced to six months of pre-trial detention on trumped-up charges related to an alleged crime from nearly 30 years ago. Now, like thousands of other prisoners in El Salvador, they are in grave danger of dying or being killed while awaiting an opportunity to prove their innocence. Their families and legal team are not able to denounce the case publicly because the judge has imposed a rare gag order. These arbitrary arrests are deeply concerning as they violate both El Salvador’s internationally recognized Peace Agreement and the National Reconciliation Law, both signed in 1992.

 

CALL FOR SUPPORT

As part of the international campaign to defend the historic mining ban, and to call for the immediate release of the Water Defenders, environmental organizations in El Salvador and their International Allies who have historically opposed metallic mining are calling for international days of action to start on (or around) April 22 (Earth Day) and to finish on April 30th.

We are asking groups like yours to join Salvadoran social movement organizations in organizing solidarity actions to take place in cities around the world. Together, we can help to raise international awareness of the country’s political crisis and to show urgently needed solidarity with the Salvadoran social movements and the community of Santa Marta.

 

WHAT CAN YOU DO

  • Help us spread the word by sharing this call to action and the social media banners below with your social networks.

  • Organize a picket in front of the Salvadoran Embassy or Consulate in your city calling for the immediate release of the Water Defenders.

  • Organize a social media event (we’ll provide the messaging and targets!)

  • Organize an event (forum, workshop, or movie night).

  • Lobby lawmakers in your country to make a statement in support of the Santa Marta 5 defenders.

  • Donate or help fundraise for the legal defense fund for the Santa Marta 5. (CLIK HERE DONATIONS IN THE US)


Opinion: Nevada can’t shed its ugly past while continuing to exploit Native people and lands

A man with a walking stick stands in front of a desert mountain
Paul Jackson, an artist and spokesman for the Fort Mojave Indian Tribe, at Avi Kwa Ame, or Spirit Mountain. The Nevada site, considered sacred by many peoples, was designated as a national monument in March.
(Genaro Molina / Los Angeles Times)
BY TAYLOR ROSE
APRIL 2, 2023 3 AM PT
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Show more sharing options

Today, tourists from all over the world flock to Nevada to experience selective amnesia. “What happens in Vegas stays in Vegas,” the slogan goes. But Las Vegas’ culture of forgetting is more than drunken hijinks. The city’s existence depends on forgetting the colonial violence that made the Southwest. Since becoming a state in 1864, Nevada’s basic political and economic infrastructure is a product of the expropriation of Native American lands.

If any one Nevadan represents this history, it’s Patrick “Pat” Anthony McCarran, the Democratic U.S. senator who served the state from 1933 to 1954. McCarran’s name is everywhere in Vegas: on street signs, building names and, until 2021, the Las Vegas International Airport. Many locals remember McCarran for being a champion of the mining and ranching industries; less proudly, they have come to recognize that he was an unabashed antisemite.

For this reason, Clark County commissioners recently rebranded the airport for a different Democratic senator, Harry Reid. Still, in reckoning with McCarran’s legacy, Nevadans sometimes overlook the ways in which even his most laudable successes carried on an ugly tradition of stealing from Indigenous people.

Dispossession began before McCarran’s time, in the 19th century. After Mexico ceded its northern territory to the United States in 1848, decades of violence ensued between white newcomers and Native nations defending their land. In 1863, near what is now the Utah-Nevada border, Western Shoshone leaders signed the Treaty of Ruby Valley for the sake of “peace and friendship.” The treaty acknowledged Native jurisdiction over much of the Intermountain West from Death Valley to Idaho’s Snake River.

Except for limited rights of way, forts and mines, Shoshone delegates neither ceded nor sold any real estate to the federal government. Nevertheless, Nevada became a state the next year, on Oct. 31, 1864. As American settlers began arriving in droves, they treated Newe (Western Shoshone) land — along with that of the nearby Numu (Northern Paiute), Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) and Washoe nations — as “public domain,” empty for the taking.

McCarran’s father had moved west in 1857 with the California Volunteers, a division of the U.S. Army charged with pacifying Natives along the Sierra Nevada’s eastern slope. After serving, he built a ranch on the lower Truckee River, east of Reno. His son, Pat, was born on Aug. 8, 1876, and grew up on the homestead

Although the younger McCarran was raised to think Native people were vanishing, in reality they were simply adapting to the settler invasion. Some relocated to reservations. Others resettled on the outskirts of mining towns. But most continued to visit traditional territories to gather pine nuts, hunt jackrabbits and perform ceremonies. They also began to mobilize, pursuing treaty rights in the courts as early as the 1920s.

In any event, McCarran inherited his father’s sense of Manifest Destiny. When he entered politics, anti-Indigenous ideas informed his policymaking in ways that continue to shape present-day Nevada. Even as he achieved national influence, serving on the Senate’s powerful Appropriations and Judiciary committees, he pursued parochial goals in his underdeveloped home state. Often his initiatives involved systematically denying Native Nevadans access to resources — particularly water — while redirecting them to his growth-minded constituents.

In one episode, McCarran went out of his way to enable non-Native squatters on the Pyramid Lake Indian Reservation, which he called a matter “of equity and justice toward the white settlers.” Avery Winnemucca, the Pyramid Lake tribal chairman, wrote to Eleanor Roosevelt in 1949, imploring her to lobby Congress against bills McCarran proposed, which would have patented the settlers’ illegal homesteads retroactively. “In defeat our ancestors accepted the white man’s treaties and promises,” Winnemucca reminded the former first lady. “Then why does Sen. McCarran propose the Congress of the U.S. to blow its nose on the American flag?” Although the immediate bills died, non-Native farmers would continue to contest the reservation’s limited water supply for decades after.

McCarran also pursued his vision of aggressive growth by soliciting military installations on the Nevada desert’s vast, “open” public lands. Nellis Air Force Base (originally an airstrip called McCarran Field, north of Las Vegas) and Naval Air Station Fallon near Reno, both established during World War II at McCarran’s urging, today represent two of the largest defense properties in the United States.

His crowning achievement came in 1950, with the creation of America’s first permanent continental nuclear weapons testing site, the Nevada Proving Grounds (later, the Nevada Test Site). Over the next 40 years, the Atomic Energy Commission (later, the Department of Energy) would detonate nearly a thousand fission devices above and below the 1,300-square-mile restricted zone.

The site was in the heart of the territory of the Western Shoshone, which they call Newe Segobia. In the 1980s, citing violations of the Ruby Valley Treaty, Newe land defenders, along with non-Indigenous pacifists and environmentalists, began protesting outside its gates. The coalition of organizers drew thousands of demonstrators to the desert each spring to peacefully gather and pray for an end to colonial occupation.

To this day, much of the region remains a highly restricted — and toxic — military zone. Native downwinders suffer some of the highest rates of cancer in the nation, probably related to radiation exposure from consuming contaminated game and wild plants in traditional diets.

Pat McCarran achieved his vision for the desert: When he died in 1954, Las Vegas was one of the fastest growing cities in the country. Southern Nevada now contains over 2 million people, with a Native population of less than 1%.

Growth continues to be a point of pride for state leaders. Recent development measures include expanding the Naval range’s footprint, doubling down on wasteful settler water laws, and transforming Nevada into a “lithium loop,” an all-in-state critical-mineral supply chain. Despite allowing for more citizen and tribal participation — and an ostensibly “green” goal in lithium-ion battery production — the current development agenda channels McCarran’s extractive goals and disregard for Native land rights.

In some ways, things are getting better. Nevadans are rethinking McCarran’s legacy in public spaces. And last month, after years of advocacy efforts by Indigenous land defenders, the Biden administration established a half-million-acre national monument surrounding Avi Kwa Ame, or Spirit Mountain, in southern Nevada. The designation will, at last, protect land considered sacred by Yuman-speaking people of the lower Colorado River.

But decolonizing Nevada will require a more fundamental reevaluation of basic ideas about development, growth and resource exploitation at the core of the state’s economy. Although the region faces a megadrought, McCarran’s vision still drives much of the state’s policies. Until that changes, Nevada, along with much of the American West, is living on stolen land and borrowed time.

Taylor Rose is a PhD candidate at Yale University. He researches mining, militarization and Native American history in the American West. This article was produced in partnership with Zócalo Public Square.


Oil & Water Don't Mix

Pamela --

You'll like a beautifully written article in the Sierra Club's magazine, Sierra, because it's helping to elevate the work to shut down the Enbridge crude oil pipeline nationally. A Battle for the Future of the Great Lakes highlights the ongoing battle between those who care about humans and the environment and the Canadian company Enbridge over the future of the Line 5 crude oil pipeline in the Great Lakes.

Sierra Magazine Story about Line 5

You know the dangers. The Line 5 pipeline threatens the Great Lakes with a devastating oil spill every day it operates. The article lifts the many voices calling for an immediate shutdown and urges people to call on the Biden administration to shut it down. Several Oil & Water Don't Mix members are featured.

Please join the thousands who have already called President Biden to shut down the pipeline. Not only is it important to take this action, but we made it super easy to take action now.

MESSAGE BIDEN

It is crazy to think that this 70-year-old crude oil pipeline is still operating and threatening the Great Lakes daily. Thanks for staying involved in the work to protect this internationally significant body of water for the good of our economy and life itself.

Bill Latka
Digital Coordinator, OWDM
Oil & Water Don't Mix


Free Leonard Peltier Imprisoned 48 years today, Feb 6, 2023

Peltier2

Sign the petition to Pres Biden

Facts About the Case

  • Leonard Peltier is an imprisoned Native American considered by Amnesty International, the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, National Congress of American Indians, the Robert F. Kennedy Memorial Center for Human Rights, Archbishop Desmond Tutu and Rev. Jesse Jackson, among many others, to be a political prisoner who should be immediately released.

  • Leonard Peltier was convicted for the deaths of two FBI agents who died during a 1975 shoot-out on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation. Mr. Peltier has been in prison for over 29 years.

  • The Wounded Knee occupation of 1973 marked the beginning of a three-year period of political violence on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation. The tribal chairman hired vigilantes, self titled as “GOONS,” to rid the reservation of American Indian Movement (AIM) activity and sentiment. More than 60 traditional tribal members and AIM members were murdered and scores more were assaulted. Evidence indicated GOON responsibility in the majority of crimes but despite a large FBI presence, nothing was done to stop the violence. The FBI supplied the GOONS with intelligence on AIM members and looked away as GOONS committed crimes. One former GOON member reported that the FBI supplied him with armor piercing ammunition.

  • Leonard Peltier was an AIM leader and was asked by traditional people at Pine Ridge, South Dakota, to support and protect the traditional people being targeted for violence. Mr. Peltier and a small group of young AIM members set up camp on a ranch owned by the traditional Jumping Bull family.

  • On June 26, 1975 two FBI agents in unmarked cars followed a pick-up truck onto the Jumping Bull ranch. The families immediately became alarmed and feared an attack. Shots were heard and a shoot-out erupted. More than 150 agents, GOONS, and law enforcement surrounded the ranch.

  • When the shoot-out ended the two FBI agents and one Native American lay dead. The agents were injured in the shoot-out and were then shot at close range. The Native American, Joseph Stuntz, was shot in the head by a sniper’s bullet. Mr. Stuntz’s death has never been investigated, nor has anyone ever been charged in connection with his death.

  • According to FBI documents, more than 40 Native Americans participated in the gunfight, but only AIM members Bob Robideau, Darrell Butler, and Leonard Peltier were brought to trial.

  • Mr. Robideau and Mr. Butler were arrested first and went to trial. A federal jury in Iowa acquitted them on grounds of self-defense, finding that their participation in the shoot-out was justified given the climate of fear that existed on the Pine Ridge Reservation. Further, they could not be tied to the close-range shootings.

  • Leonard Peltier was arrested in Canada on February 6, 1976, along with Frank Blackhorse, a.k.a. Frank Deluca. The United States presented the Canadian court with affidavits signed by Myrtle Poor Bear who said she was Mr. Peltier’s girlfriend and allegedly saw him shoot the agents. In fact, Ms. Poor Bear had never met Mr. Peltier and was not present during the shoot-out. Soon after, Ms. Poor Bear recanted her statements and said the FBI threatened her and coerced her into signing the affidavits.

  • Mr. Peltier was extradited to the United States where he was tried in 1977. The trial was held in North Dakota before United States District Judge Paul Benson, a conservative jurist appointed to the federal bench by Richard M. Nixon. Key witnesses like Myrtle Poor Bear were not allowed to testify and unlike the Robideau/Butler trial in Iowa, evidence regarding violence on Pine Ridge was severely restricted.

  • An FBI agent who had previously testified that the agents followed a pick-up truck onto the scene, a vehicle that could not be tied to Mr. Peltier, changed his account, stating that the agents had followed a red and white van onto the scene, a vehicle which Mr. Peltier drove occasionally.

  • Three teenaged Native witnesses testified against Mr. Peltier, they all later admitted that the FBI forced them to testify. Still, not one witness identified Mr. Peltier as the shooter.

  • The U.S. Attorney prosecuting the case claimed that the government had provided the defense with all FBI documents concerning the case. To the contrary, more than 140,000 pages had been withheld in their entirety.

  • An FBI ballistics expert testified that a casing found near the agents’ bodies matched the gun tied to Mr. Peltier. However, a ballistic test proving that the casing did not come from the gun tied to Mr. Peltier was intentionally concealed.

  • The jury, unaware of the aforementioned facts, found Mr. Peltier guilty. Judge Benson, in turn, sentenced Mr. Peltier to two consecutive life terms.

  • Following the discovery of new evidence obtained through a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit, Mr. Peltier sought a new trial. The Eighth Circuit ruled, “There is a possibility that the jury would have acquitted Leonard Peltier had the records and data improperly withheld from the defense been available to him in order to better exploit and reinforce the inconsistencies casting strong doubts upon the government's case." Yet, the court denied Mr. Peltier a new trial.

  • During oral argument, the government attorney conceded that the government does not know who shot the agents, stating that Mr. Peltier is equally guilty whether he shot the agents at point-blank range, or participated in the shoot-out from a distance. Mr. Peltier’s co-defendants participated in the shoot-out from a distance, but were acquitted.

  • Judge Heaney, who authored the decision denying a new trial, has since voiced firm support for Mr. Peltier’s release, stating that the FBI used improper tactics to convict Mr. Peltier, the FBI was equally responsible for the shoot-out, and that Mr. Peltier's release would promote healing with Native Americans.

  • Mr. Peltier has served over 29 years in prison and is long overdue for parole. He has received several human rights awards for his good deeds from behind bars which include annual gift drives for the children of Pine Ridge, fund raisers for battered women’s shelters, and donations of his paintings to Native American recovery programs.

  • Mr. Peltier suffers from diabetes, high blood pressure, and a heart condition. Time for justice is short.

  • Currently, Mr. Peltier’s attorneys have filed a new round of Freedom of Information Act requests with FBI Headquarters and all FBI field offices in an attempt to secure the release of all files relating to Mr. Peltier and the RESMURS investigation. To date, the FBI has engaged in a number of dilatory tactics in order to avoid the processing of these requests.
Save our Menominee River! Sacred Site of the Menominee Nation
Saving the Menominee River to protect our water, air, soils, aquatic life, wildlife, and people from the dangers of open-pit metallic sulfide mining is very important! There has never been a safe sulfide mine!
Information
https://youtu.be/iiOllFTNZz4
https://youtu.be/cilsGzrf1-g

The Lasting Harms of Toxic Exposure in Native American Communities

Berkeley Review

BY SANJANA MANJESHWAR 

“They never told us uranium was dangerous. We washed our faces in it. We drank in it. We ate in it. It was sweet,” explained Cecilia Joe, an 85-year-old Navajo woman, in a recent interview. Joe’s experience illustrates the under-researched but extremely pervasive problem of environmental injustice on Native American reservations. 

Due to decades of harmful environmental policy and exploitation by private companies, Native communities have been disproportionately subjected to toxic waste, pollution and other health risks — leading to what some activists describe as “environmental genocide.” Out of all the ethnic groups in the United States, Native Americans are the most at risk of toxic exposure, a fact that reflects broader realities about the continued oppression of Native communities and has galvanized Native activists into seeking justice. 

While the word “reservation” may invoke ideas of protection or sanctuary, historically, Native American reservations have systematically been targeted as sites for toxic waste disposal, and the U.S. government has historically been indifferent towards this. Companies “hoping to take advantage of the devastating chronic unemployment, pervasive poverty, and sovereign status of Indian nations” offer millions of dollars to Native American tribes in exchange for the ability to dispose of toxic waste, according to Bradley Angel in a report for the environmental organization Greenpeace. 

Native American reservations have some of the highest poverty rates in the country, and may feel inclined to accept these companies’ financial offers, despite the ensuing environmental degradation and health impacts. For instance, some residents of the Skull Valley Indian Reservation actually support the storage of nuclear waste on their land because of the economic opportunities it will create, while other residents are adamantly opposed to it. As a result, Native Americans are 1.8 times more likely than any other ethnic group to live near toxic waste facilities.

For instance, the Yakama Nation, a tribe located in southwest Washington, is surrounded on three sides by Superfund sites — areas designated by the U.S. government as the most contaminated and polluted locations in the country. Portland Harbor, which the tribe relies on for fish and other resources, has been heavily contaminated by petroleum, pesticides and other toxic chemicals at levels dangerous to human health, forcing the Yakama people to restructure their way of life. Although the Yakama Nation has been advocating for Portland Harbor to be cleaned up for over thirty years, the companies responsible for the contamination have continually delayed and obstructed the cleanup. 

Toxic exposure has led to devastating and long-lasting health impacts in Native American communities. Members of the Mohawk Nation at Akwesasne have historically fished in the St. Lawrence River in New York, which has been contaminated by hydraulic fluids leaking from aluminum factories in the area. As a result, the Mohawk people have consistently been found to have elevated levels of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) in their bloodstreams, which has caused them to have a higher risk of diabetes and cancer. 

Similarly, the Yupik people of St. Lawrence Island in Alaska have PCB levels in their blood that are 4 -12 times higher than the levels of the general U.S. population, presumably because of hazardous waste from abandoned military sites — leading to increases in cancer rates, birth defects, and miscarriages. In the late 1990s, Yupik environmental activist Annie Alowa asked the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to clean up the military base on the northeast part of the island, highlighting the impact on her community’s health, but her concerns were dismissed. Alowa, who died of cancer in 1999, claimed that her breast cancer and liver cancer were a direct result of environmental contaminants on the island. 

Annie Alowa at a contaminated site on St. Lawrence Island. / Alaska Community Action on Toxics

The legacy of environmental racism towards Native Americans is also inseparable from the United States’ history of nuclear development and military innovation. From the 1940s to the 1980s, the Navajo Nation was one of the most plentiful uranium mining sites in the country — the U.S. government extracted over four million tons of uranium ore from sites on the reservation to make nuclear weapons. Navajo people who lived near uranium mines were not warned about the hazards of radiation, and experienced alarmingly high rates of lung cancer, leukemia, kidney disease, birth defects and several other health issues. Mining companies later abandoned these mines without cleaning up the large quantities of uranium on the reservation; even today, the Navajo people continue to suffer adverse health effects related to radiation. The Oglala Lakota people living at the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in South Dakota, which also has an extensive history of uranium mining, have a cancer mortality rate that is 40 percent higher than that of the overall population. 

In the 1960s, the U.S. government tested dioxin, a chemical used in Agent Orange, on the lands of the San Carlos Apache Tribe in Arizona. Exposure to Agent Orange, a powerful chemical herbicide used to control vegetation during the Vietnam War, famously led to catastrophic health complications for Vietnam veterans. Members of the San Carlos Apache Tribe tribe claim that this dioxin experimentation  led to similarly devastating illnesses and health complications in their own community, including cancer, heart disease, and neurological disorders.

 And at the Dugway Proving Ground, located immediately outside the Skull Valley Indian Reservation, the U.S. government has tested VX, an extremely toxic military-grade poison gas, for decades. In 1968, over 6,000 sheep owned by Skull Valley Goshute Native Americans died after exposure to this nerve agent — yet the military continues to conduct experiments there, despite the obvious health and safety risks to the reservation’s residents.

November 1979, Navajo Nation / AP
March 2020, Navajo Nation / Caylee Scott

 

 

 

 

 

 

The extent of toxic exposure in Native communities reflects the U.S. government’s tendency to view Native American reservations, and by extension, Native American people, as expendable. Since this country’s inception, Native American policy in the United States has largely been characterized by violence, abandonment, and disinvestment — it comes as no surprise that the government (with the support of private companies) values profit and resources over the health and well-being of the people it has oppressed for centuries. Although toxic waste exposure might not seem like an intentional or malicious attempt to harm Native American communities, the systematic exploitation of Native land and the lack of attention given to the ensuing health effects represents this country’s callous disregard for some of its most vulnerable citizens. 

Despite the seemingly irreparable harm that has already been committed, some Native activists still see potential paths to achieving environmental justice. The recent confirmation of Deb Haaland — the first-ever Native American Cabinet Secretary — as the Secretary of the Interior signals the willingness of the Biden Administration to address issues affecting Native communities, including toxic exposure. While the Interior department has historically been used as a tool of oppression towards Native Americans, Haaland has displayed a strong commitment towards advancing environmental justice and prioritizing Native voices. 

Native Americans affected by toxic exposure have also frequently turned to the courts to seek compensation for the harm that they have experienced. The Navajo Nation, for example, obtained a settlement of $600 million from two nuclear companies to clean up abandoned uranium mines. Similarly, the Yakama Nation filed a lawsuit against several polluting companies and government entities, including ExxonMobil and the City of Portland, seeking reimbursement for the hundreds of thousands of dollars it will cost to clean up the Portland Harbor. 

In 1997, thousands of Native American individuals living near the Hanford Nuclear Facility in Washington filed a class action lawsuit against the U.S. government for “infliction of radiological injuries,” seeking damages for the health issues caused by the facility’s radiation. While this case was set to be heard by a jury, the jury trial was cancelled in 2013, with plaintiffs receiving undisclosed monetary settlements from the Hanford contractors after nearly twenty years of negotiations. Although no amount of money can necessarily compensate for the trauma inflicted by environmental injustice, litigation can potentially help achieve access to justice for Native communities harmed by pollution and contamination. 

Evan Abell / Yakima Herald-Republic

Native American activists have been outspoken in their opposition to environmental injustice for decades — while some might be inclined to view Native communities as passive or complacent in the face of toxic exposure, Native environmental activism has been defined by outrage and organized resistance. Several Native American-led environmental organizations, including the Indigenous Environmental Network, the Native American Environmental Protection Coalition and the American Lands Alliance have been raising awareness about toxic exposure and environmental injustice against Native Americans for decades. 

For instance, in the late 1980s, Navajo activists formed a group called Diné Citizens Against Ruining our Environment (CARE), which successfully fought the construction of a proposed toxic waste facility on Navajo land in Arizona. In the early 2000s, the Western Shoshone tribe in Nevada put up an impassioned, years-long fight against a nuclear waste storage facility at Yucca Mountain — the protesters were eventually successful as the project was defunded by the Obama Administration in 2010. And in the mid-2010s, Sioux activists at the Standing Rock Indian Reservation drew national attention to their efforts organizing against the Dakota Access Pipeline, though this protest was ultimately unsuccessful in stopping the pipeline. 

Policy solutions that might help address the toxic waste crisis on Native American reservations include banning toxic waste dumping on reservations and passing legislation that prohibits polluting entities, such as nuclear facilities or hazardous waste incinerators, from being near reservations. The U.S. government should also economically invest in Native American communities so that reservations are not financially pressured to accept money from corporations who want to dispose of waste. The Indian Health Service, a division of the Department of Health and Human Services that is responsible for providing federal health services to Native Americans, can establish an office or task force dedicated to preventing health problems that arise from environmental injustice. Lastly, providing monetary reparations to survivors of toxic exposure can help mitigate the lasting harm caused by environmental injustice, especially since the government’s approach has historically been to ignore and neglect these problems. 

Addressing the harm inflicted by toxic exposure on Native American reservations will require sustained and equitable policy approaches that prioritize the interests of individuals over the interests of corporations. Above all else, the diseases and deaths caused by exposure to toxic chemicals on Native land serve as a stark reminder of the injustice that has been inflicted on Native Americans by the government and private companies for centuries. 

Featured Image Source: Grand Canyon Trust

Floyd Westerman song-

Mis hermanos, la tierra es mi madre, Mis hermanas, la tierra es tu madre Mis hermanos, somos la misma sangre Mis Hermanas, somos un solo rio Somos un solo río, cuando estamos unidos Seremos millones, y nuestro río correrá libre Mis hermanos, somos la misma sangre Mis hermanas, somos un solo río.

 

Last week, hundreds of Tribal leaders gathered at the first in-person White House Tribal Nations Summit since 2016.

President Biden and his administration’s leaders announced new steps for federal agency consultation with Tribes, as part of a commitment to honor Tribal sovereignty. These are steps in the right direction. Ultimately, tribal consultation must be codified into law.

We support the RESPECT Act, which would require federal agencies to consult with Tribal governments before taking action or permitting projects that would significantly impact Tribes. And we need even more when it comes to harmful development and extraction projects like mines, dams, and oil pipelines.

Native communities have the inherent and legal right to give or to withhold consent to these projects. The failure of federal agencies to gain the free, prior, and informed consent of Tribes is a violation of treaty rights and a flawed process that leads to the desecration of our sacred places.

Please sign if you agree: In order to fulfill the promise of respecting Native sovereignty, the Biden administration and Congress must move towards free, prior, and informed consent.

SIGN NOW

Hawwih (thank you in Caddo),

Judith Le Blanc (Caddo)
Executive Director

Rights of Nature,  by Anahkwet Reiter of the Menominee Nation.

Center for Environmental Rights

Menikanaehkem - Community Rebuilders

Rights Of Nature, Earth Democracy And The Future Of Environmental  Governance | Green AgendaNo photo description available.

Rights of Nature Slide Show 


Water is Life | Indigenous Lifeways Threatened by Enbridge’s Line 5

Indigenous Lifeways Threatened by Enbridge's Line 5 | Wisconsin Citizens  Media Cooperative

Nov 7, 2022
Tribal leaders and Native community members share how #Enbridge #Line5 currently impacts and the proposed tunnel will continue to harm Native communities in the Mackinac Straits of Michigan. Through sharing about lifeways and connection to the Straits, they affirm that #WaterIsLife. They envision Michiganders safeguarding the Great Lakes out of gratitude for the life they give and the place of gathering they provide. Michiganders powering quality of life for all with renewable energy that never risks life-giving water or the places that make life worth living. For more information: https://www.anishinaabekcaucus.org/ou... This video is a collaboration between the School of Environment and Sustainability at the University of Michigan and the Anishinaabek Caucus. Filming/Production/Editing: Steve Gute from Confluence Documentary
https://youtu.be/OCW6fiNSXjs

Michigan U.P. legislators want to erase Menominee Nation history

UPDATED: Michigan Board votes to add ancient Menominee site to National Register of Historic Places; pro-mining Michigan legislators oppose vote

By Michele Bourdieu, with information from Earth Justice*
https://keweenawnow.blogspot.com/2022/09/michigan-board-votes-to-add-ancient.html
http://www.noback40.org/

U.S. Policy in the Global South

September 19, 7pm | Zoom

Nobel Peace Laureate Dr. Rigoberta Menchú Tum, Vincent Bevins, and Amy Goodman (moderator)

This video is in English and Spanish with English subtitles. Click here to view it entirely in English or entirely in Spanish.


1

https://www.facebook.com/LeonardPeltierWalkToJustice

#leonardpeltierswalktojustice #FREELEONARDPELTIERNOW #LeonardPeltier #releaseleonardpeltier #FreeLeonardPeltier

National Walk to Free Leonard Peltier Kicks Off in Minneapolis

  • Yahoo News

The “Walk to Justice: Free Leonard Peltier” will travel from Minneapolis through Wisconsin, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, and Pennsylvania, ending in Washington, D.C. on November 14. (photo by Darren Thomspon for Native News Online)

BY DARREN THOMPSON- SEPTEMBER 01, 2022

MINNEAPOLIS—The American Indian Movement (AIM) Grand Governing Council hosted a rally yesterday in Cedar Field Park to kick off a 15-week national walk demanding the release of Leonard Peltier. 

The “Walk to Justice: Free Leonard Peltier” will travel from Minneapolis through Wisconsin, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, and Pennsylvania, ending in Washington, D.C. on November 14. 

“This is not an easy thing to plan a national walk,” Rachel Thunder, lead walk organizer and director of AIM’s True People of Indiana and Kentucky Chapter, said during the rally. “This walk wouldn’t be possible without all of our communities coming together along the way. Our brothers and sisters are going to suffer at this ceremony, just as Leonard has suffered for our people.”

Peltier, a member of the Turtle Mountain Band of Chippewa Indians, was convicted of aiding and abetting in the murder of two Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) agents on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in June 1975. His co-defendants, Dino Butler and Robert Robideau, were charged with two counts of murder and were acquitted under claims of self-defense. 

The charge of aiding and abetting allows a court to convict someone guilty of a crime even if they are not the principal offender.

“Who could he have aided and abetted?” Lisa Bellanger, co-director of AIM’s Grand Convening Council, asked yesterday’s crowd. “We asked the federal government to release our elder and to release him now. And we told them that if it doesn’t happen, we’ll lift the spirit of the people, and we’ll walk to D.C.”

Many organizations have advocated for the release of Peltier and consider him America’s political prisoner. The federal appellate judge who oversaw Peltier’s appeal case, Gerald Heaney, later wrote a letter to former Chair on Senate Select Committee on Indian Affairs Daniel Inouye in 1991 stating that the FBI conducted an improper investigation in securing Peltier’s extradition from Canada. 

“Although our Court decided that these actions were not grounds for reversal, they are, in my view, factors that merit consideration in any petition for leniency filed,” Heaney wrote in 1991. 

Peltier has been in prison for 46 years. 

“The first time I’ve seen my dad was when I was two years old,” Peltier’s daughter, Kathy Peltier, said at yesterday’s rally.

Kathy was born in November 1975, months after the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation shootout in June of that year that led to Peltier’s conviction.

“I’ve been speaking about my dad since I could speak, and we know in our hearts that our dad is free,” Kathy said.

“The day of the shootout in 1975, the FBI created a narrative that some super soldier killed two FBI agents,” Dr. Nick Estes said during the rally. “But they don’t tell you that the vast majority of people at that shootout were under the age of 18.” 

Musicians Mitch Walking Elk and Robby Romero closed the evening with performances and stories on their lifetime advocating for the release of Leonard Peltier. In 1992, both musicians performed at the United States Federal Penitentiary in Leavenworth, Kansas. 

For more information on the walk, please follow the “Walk to Justice: Free Leonard Peltier” Facebook page. Rallies and events will be hosted along the walk, with a convening in Washington, D.C. on November 14, 2022.

Wisconsin Tribes and environmentalists say Wisconsin failed to fully review Enbridge Line 5 oil pipeline project's risks.

The pipeline spans 645 miles from Superior across northern Wisconsin and Michigan before ending in Sarnia, Ontario. It carries up to 23 million gallons of Canadian crude oil and natural gas liquids each day.

Bad River Tribe Files Federal Lawsuit Against Enbridge, the northern Wisconsin Tribe Wants Enbridge To Remove Line 5 from it's Reservation Lands. 

The tribe's legal challenge, first mounted in 2019, is now entering its fourth year as Enbridge seeks state and federal permits to build a new 30-inch pipeline that would run roughly41 miles around the tribe's reservation. For tribal officials and activists, the tour of the pipeline’s route presented an opportunity to see the potential risks of the project firsthand. Naomi Tillison, the tribe's director of the Mashkiiziibii Natural Resources Department, said the tribal council previously rejected renewal of pipeline easements due to the threat of an oil spill.

The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources is the lead state agency permitting the $450 million project. In December, it released a draft environmental review of the company’s plan that critics blasted as incomplete and flawed. Now, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency says the state's review failed to fully analyze the ways in which the project could harm the environment, as well as tribal resources and treaty rights.

This is the public's opportunity to voice our opposition to Line 5, or a replacement pipeline, being permitted in Wisconsin.

Line 5 Tunnel Project in the Straits of Mackinac

DEPT OF ARMY, DETROIT DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS 

Published August 15, 2022 / Expiration date: October 14, 2022 

Notice of Intent to Prepare an EIS published in the Federal Register for the proposed Enbridge Line 5 Tunnel Project in the Straits of Mackinac, Emmet and Mackinac Counties, Michigan 

Subject: This Public Notice announces the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Detroit District’s (Corps) Notice of Intent (NOI) to prepare a Draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) and to seek input under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (Section 106) for the proposed Enbridge Line 5 Tunnel Project in the Straits of Mackinac, Emmet and Mackinac Counties, Michigan. The NOI, along with additional information on the project, is available at the following website: https://www.Line5TunnelEIS.com.  

The Corps invites all interested parties to provide comments on the identification of and potential effects to historic properties during the EIS scoping period. Visit the project website at https://www.Line5TunnelEIS.com to view the NOI, submit comments, or for information on the proposed project and the Corps’ scoping process. 

A paper copy of the NOI may be requested by phone at 313-887-1757 or by mail to: Line 5 Tunnel EIS, 16501 Shady Grove Road, P.O. Box 10178, Gaithersburg, MD 20898.  Scoping comments may also be submitted by mail to this address. 

Public Scoping Meeting Dates Announced for the Enbridge Line 5 Tunnel EIS

  • October 6, 1:00-4:00 PM Eastern (Virtual): https://us06web.zoom.us/j/82961743672 or by phone 309-205-3325 using Webinar ID: 829 6174 3672

Kayanlaˀ Kówa – Great Law of Peace

The Peace Maker & Hiawatha

At one time the Haudenoshaunee people were in mixed emotions with one another. During this time a lot of the people started to feud with each other violently. It was getting so bad that the Creator started to notice and he felt that he needed to send the people a message of what their duties are when they are on Mother Earth. He sent his message through a man named Two Rows of Teeth, otherwise known as the Peacemaker. The Peacemaker received the Creators message in a dream. The Creator told him to spread this word of peace to the Haudenosaunee people.
The Peacemaker decided to start in the East and head west. He met another man named Hiawatha. Hiawatha was a Seneca man who was married into the Mohawk people. When the Peacemaker met with Hiawatha, Hiawatha was mourning the loss of his family. In the matter of three years he lost his wife and three daughters. He was very heart sick and sad.The Peacemaker told him the message he received from the Creator. Hiawatha accepted this message and offered to help the Peacemaker spread the message to the Haudenosaunee people. They went on their way and took the message to the people in the Mohawk village. The Mohawks were hesitant in taking the message but they agreed. The Peacemaker and Hiawatha then went to the Oneida village and they too accepted the message. The they went to the Onondaga people who challenged the Peacemaker and Hiawatha by saying that if they could convince the wicked man, Tadadaho, who was a sorcerer, then they would believe. The two men tried and tried but could not succeed. They left the Onondagas and moved on to the Cayuga village. The Cayuga people accepted the message. Then the Peacemaker and Hiawatha went to the Seneca village, and they too accepted the message.The two men then went back to convince the Onondaga people of the message. They said only if they could convince Tadadaho. The two took on the challenge again and they tried to get him to listen to the message. Every time they would get close, something evil would happen. When they asked people to try and help them, Tadadaho would use his evil powers to hurt or even kill the men who tried to help. As the Peacemaker and Hiawatha tried their hardest they finally got to him, but by this point Tadadaho’s powers were so strong that they were all around the two men. They gave him the message and Tadadaho challenged it with his evil magic, but to no avail. The two men then helped Tadadaho by clearing his mind and helping him see straight. After they helped Tadadaho, the rest of the Onondaga people accepted the Great Law of Peace.

Government of the 5 Nations & Iroquois Confederacy

Our government consists of 50 chiefs from the entire Iroquois confederacy. The Clan Mothers, Chiefs, and Faithkeepers run the Iroquois confederacy. Each person has a specific responsibility for the people. The Iroquois confederacy had an influence on how our country is run today. In 1754, Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson has gone to visit the chiefs. At the time they were creating the Articles of Confederation for the 13 colonies because they were not states yet. An excerpt from a longer piece written by Benjamin Franklin about 1784. Franklin clearly does not regard Native Americans as “savages”: he is using the term for ironic effect. The “savages” are, in fact, as civilized or more civilized than the Whites: it is the Whites who must rely upon force, punishment, and prisons to enforce good behavior”. Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson were amazed at how disciplined and organized our government was. They observed very closely and then created what today is the United States Constitution.

Tuscarora join and we become the 6 Nations

In 1716, the Tuscarora people were and the end of a bloody and tragic civil war with the Cherokee and Choctaw people. The Tuscarora people fled north to Iroquois territory and asked for help. They were then taken in under the wing of the Oneida people. The Tuscarora were later adopted in 1722 and made up the sixth nation to the Iroquois Confederacy.

The Original Story of Wampum and the Wampum Belts

Wampum comes from Quahog clamshells found at the bottom of lakes and rivers. Many people think that the Haudenosaunee used wampum as money. That was not true. Wampum was used as a history tool containing a binding story of either a treaty, or a significant agreement or a law for the people. It was also used as a marker for dates and held the Haudenosaunee history. The wampum is made into beads and then strung together to create a belt. Each belt tells a story of the Haudenoshaunee people.
Hiawatha brought wampum to the Haudenosaunee. He needed something that the people knew was pure and held truth within itself. The Hiawatha received the wampum from the Creator when he came to a lake and had no way of crossing it. The lake was covered with ducks. When he came to the lake he asked the Creator to show him how to get across the lake. As soon as he asked all the ducks started to flap their wings and it cleared a pathway. The pathway was made up of the Quahog clamshells. Hiawatha had seen all different shades of purple and the whitest white he had ever seen. So he took some of the clamshells and made them into beads. The ducks cleared a path and also gave Hiawatha the gift of wampum. Today the stories that are associated with the wampum belts are still being told as a reminder that these belts are still a law, treaty, or a space in Haudensaunee history.


Sign up for a free First Nations Wisconsin newsletter

The state is home to 12 tribal nations and the newsletter is named for these 12 tribes, which are Menominee, Oneida, Ho-Chunk, Potawatomi, Mohican, Brothertown and the six Ojibwe nations of Lac du Flambeau, Lac Courte Oreilles, Bad River, Red Cliff, Sokaogon and St. Croix.

The First Nations Wisconsin newsletter is emailed every Wednesday and will feature the most recent tribal news and highlight other issues affecting Indigenous nations and people.

https://www.greenbaypressgazette.com/story/news/native-american-issues/2021/07/07/wisconsin-native-american-issues-sign-up-first-nations-newsletter/7827711002/


Treaty People Convergence

Aug. 5 - 7, 2022 

We are all “Treaty People.” Enbridge Pipelines are in violation of our treaties. 

May be an image of text

For questions or concerns, please call Timothy at 608-630-3633.


In the Michigan UP, a new chapter begins in 20-year clash over "Back 40" gold mine

  • Published: Aug. 04, 2022
  • Back Forty gold mine planned in Upper Peninsula
  • Garret Ellison | [email protected]

 

MENOMINEE, MI — Guy “Anahkwet” Reiter was in his twenties when he first began actively opposing an open-pit gold mine along the banks of the Menominee River.

Today, Reiter is 42 and has three kids. But the years haven’t tamed his dislike for the proposed Back Forty mine near Stephenson in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, which he says he would lay down his life to try and stop.

“If I have to stand in front of the machines and give my life up, then that’s what I’m willing to do,” said Reiter, a citizen of the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin.

It has been 20 years since drilling confirmed the existence of gold along the Menominee River; sparking fears that a mine would eventually despoil the landscape and launching a two decade fight to keep the minerals in the ground.

Whereas another UP mine discovered its deposit and began production during that timeframe, the gold, silver, copper, zinc and lead at the end of the rainbow in Menominee County are no closer to market today than they were in 2015 when former mine owner Aquila Resources submitted its first permit applications to the state of Michigan.

However, that could change soon. A new owner, Gold Resources Corp., is redesigning the mine’s operational footprint to assuage environmental concerns and broaden support in what’s generally a mining-friendly region ahead of a new round of permitting applications, which company officials expect to submit this or early next year.

Back Forty officials say they’re aiming for a “no net loss” impact on wetlands — a sticky wicket that derailed the last permitting attempt. In early 2021, an administrative law judge overturned Aquila’s state permit to fill wetlands, finding the application incomplete and lacking an adequate assessment of potential alternatives to their loss.

Under the new design, the pit size has been reduced and moved further from the river. More mining would take place underground than under the previous design — but not all of it. Gold Resources also plans to “dry stack” its tailings, or milled waste rock, rather than build a slurry basin that would require another permit to build an earthen tailings dam.

“We started from scratch,” said Dave Anderson, general manager of the Back Forty mine. “I’m quite confident that our wetland impact reduction will be very dramatic.”

“I’m comfortable saying that at the end of mine life, upon reclamation, that those wetlands that are on site will be intact; they will be ecologically functioning and providing the environmental services, if you will, that they currently provide,” said Anderson.

New owner wants to begin mining in three years

In December, Gold Resources completed its acquisition of Aquila — adding a second project alongside its only other; the Don David gold mine complex in Oaxaca, Mexico.

The company paid $23.9 million for Aquila, which investment analysts considered a bargain price considering the value under the Menominee forest — an estimated 468,000 ounces of gold worth $259 million at $1,300 per ounce over seven years of mining.

Gold is the most valuable, but isn’t anywhere near the largest volume of mineral in the Back Forty deposit — a 1.8 billion-year-old creation formed by hydrothermal seafloor vents during the Paleoproterozoic Era, a time when small islands of early Earth crust were beginning to stabilize into continents. The deposit rests in what’s called the Penokean Volcanic Belt.

Intermingled with gold is an estimated 512 million pounds of zinc, 51 million pounds of copper, 24 million pounds of lead and 4 million pounds of silver. However, it will cost a mint to unearth that material — more than $290 million, according to Aquila estimates.

The company thinks there may be more minerals under the known deposit, which, if confirmed as extractable, could extend the mine’s lifespan and increase its profitability.

If built, previous company estimates have put the state of Michigan’s mineral royalties at $16.5 million over the mine lifespan.

Gold Resources is performing a feasibility study this year to determine, essentially, if developing the project is worth the effort. Permit applications and mining plans are in concurrent development. The company is estimating it will take about a year-and-a-half to acquire permits and get through expected administrative challenges from opponents.

The goal is to begin Back Forty construction in 2024 and start mining production in 2025, according to a March 11 earnings call with company CEO Allen Palmiere.

To the Menominee tribe, all that glitters isn’t gold.

“We’re pretty much anti-mining, in general,” said tribal chairman Ronald Corn, Sr.

“I know that mining companies state that they’re able to do safe mines, but we’ve never seen that demonstrated anywhere,” said Corn. “It’s just a matter of time before something happens that that impacts the environment.”

Tribe, environmental groups worry about river pollution

The tribe is suspicious of gilded promises.

Its opposition is rooted in fear that the mine will contaminate the river and trample on historic cultural sites in the immediate area. Ancient tribal burial mounds and garden beds dot River Road where the mine is planned. The tribe is also uniquely tied to the river mouth as a point of origin, where its history holds that its five ancestral clans were created.

The tribe has allies in the environmental realm. In 2017 and 2020, the American Rivers conservation nonprofit listed the Menominee River as among the nation’s “most endangered.” There are ongoing efforts to list the river “Dog’s Belly” and “60 Islands” areas near the mine on the National Register of Historic Places to bulk up legal hurdles to development.

Dale Burie, co-founder of the Coalition to Save the Menominee River, ins’t buying claims the mine can be designed to minimize environmental harms.

“We don’t want to expose the Menominee River to contaminated acid mine drainage,” Burie said. “It’s a world class smallmouth bass and walleye fishery, and a major breeding ground for historic lake sturgeon.”

In the UP, the Superior Watershed Partnership and Land Conservancy opposes the mine and helped with the “endangered” listing. Its opposition is notable because the organization works closely with another mine that was fiercely opposed during development. Through a program that involves the Keweenaw Bay Indian Community and others, the group verifies environmental monitoring data gathered by Eagle Mine, a nickel and copper mine near Marquette that opened in 2014 after its deposit was discovered in 2002.

Eagle Mine faced significant opposition during development. The battle featured similar environmental concerns cited by opponents to the Back Forty mine. However, nearly a decade after the mine opened, those problems have not materialized.

As evidence of human-induced climate change has mounted, attitudes have softened toward Eagle Mine because nickel is a crucial component in electric vehicle (EV) batteries. Transitioning to electric vehicles is key to reducing carbon emissions from the transportation sector and mining in jurisdictions like Michigan means the minerals aren’t sourced from countries with loose environmental regulations that undercut the market’s green ethos.

However, Eagle Mine and Back Forty are not the same animal. At Eagle, all mining happens deep underground. At Back Forty, the minerals are closer to the surface. Even under the new design, an open pit of some size is anticipated as part of the project.

Also, gold is used in some circuitry, but it is not crucial to EV batteries the way nickel is. That means “it’s harder to make the case it’s part of the energy transition solution and supporting renewable energy,” said Robert Johnston, a research scholar at the Columbia University Center for Global Energy Policy.

Geraldine Grant, a senior planner and biologist at the Superior Watershed Partnership, said the group’s monitoring program with Eagle Mine has drawn significant attention from mining companies and universities interested in replicating it. However, there has been no contact from anyone connected to Back Forty.

“We still don’t want to see that mine built,” said Grant. “It’s kind of a risky area to do a mine like that.”

Mine supporters deploy climate argument

Others do want the mine built.

Opponents have struggled to win votes for the historic preservation effort among local officials. The mine also has significant support in Lansing. In January, the state’s UP delegation, including Rep. Sara Cambensy, a Democrat, released a joint statement praising the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (DNR) for renewing the mine’s lease last year.

In a letter urging the renewal, Sen. Ed McBroom, R-Vulcan, called arguments against the mine “specious” and leaned heavily into the economic contribution from Eagle Mine. McBroom drew a connection between the Back Forty deposit and the need for critical minerals as the state and nation transition away from fossil fuels.

Cambensy is co-sponsoring package legislation in the state House that would let mining companies receive state matching grants for research, development and reclamation.

“If we truly want to address climate change, you have to be open to a lot more mining,” Cambensy told a UP news station this summer. “You can’t be an advocate for climate change while opposing mining, because a green economy depends on digging up exponentially more minerals to make that transition.”

In Stephenson, Anderson appears eager to extend the olive branch and thaw relations with the tribe. He pledged that tribal heritage sites would all be protected under the new design and expressed a desire to partner on their protection.

“I would love to have a conversation with the tribe on how we can put those sites into the hands of the tribe so they can protect them in perpetuity,” Anderson said.

Whether the rapprochement effort bears fruit remains to be seen. The tribe has yet to have a conversation with the company and Corn it hasn’t really discussed the broader climate question amongst itself, either. At the moment, the plan is to remain steadfast in opposition.

“Once those permits are (being) worked on, we’re definitely going to take the same stance,” Corn said.

 


Environmentalists say Wisconsin failed to fully review Enbridge Line 5 oil pipeline project's risks. The EPA agrees.

EPA issues nearly 200 recommendations for Wisconsin DNR to strengthen its review
By Danielle Kaeding, NPR Radio
  • Monday, July 25, 2022, 5:50am
SHARE: 
Forward logo Facebook logo Twitter logo
ListenDownload

With the sun blazing overhead, tribal and environmental advocates gathered one June morning along a gravel road where a Canadian energy firm’s pipeline crosses a northern Wisconsin tribe’s reservation.

The site is part of a 12-mile stretch where the Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa has been embroiled in a yearslong legal battle with Enbridge Inc., to remove Line 5 from tribal lands. The pipeline spans 645 miles from Superior across northern Wisconsin and Michigan before ending in Sarnia, Ontario. It carries up to 23 million gallons of Canadian crude oil and natural gas liquids each day.

The tribe's legal challenge, first mounted in 2019, is now entering its fourth year as Enbridge seeks state and federal permits to build a new 30-inch pipeline that would run roughly 41 miles around the tribe's reservation. For tribal officials and activists, the tour of the pipeline’s route presented an opportunity to see the potential risks of the project firsthand. 

Naomi Tillison, the tribe's director of the Mashkiiziibii Natural Resources Department, said the tribal council previously rejected renewal of pipeline easements due to the threat of an oil spill.

"That's why the council said we are not going to do these," Tillison said. "We need to protect our water. We need to protect our wild rice beds. We need to protect our fisheries."

Bad River at Copper Falls State Park

The Bad River flowing through Copper Falls State Park. The U.S. EPA said Enbridge's proposed Line 5 project may have "substantial and unacceptable" impacts to the Bad River and Kakagon Sloughs. Danielle Kaeding/WPR

The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources is the lead state agency permitting the $450 million project. In December, it released a draft environmental review of the company’s plan that critics blasted as incomplete and flawed.

Now, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency says the state's review failed to fully analyze the ways in which the project could harm the environment, as well as tribal resources and treaty rights.

"We think that many of the comments we've provided to take climate change into account, and to do a much more thorough review of the potential impact on tributaries and on those wetlands, will assist in a better review," EPA’s Regional Administrator Debra Shore told Wisconsin Public Radio's "The Morning Show."

In March, the EPA sent a 31-page letter with nearly 200 recommendations for the DNR to strengthen its review as part of preparing a final environmental impact statement. Federal regulators say the state failed to fully analyze the risk of spills, tribal resources and treaty rights, the effects of climate change, and whether the project would violate state and tribal water quality standards.

The EPA has shared authority with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to ensure those who apply for permits meet requirements under the Clean Water Act. The federal agency has invoked its authority to request that Enbridge's application receives a higher level of review, and the EPA has been meeting with the Army Corps and DNR to ensure the agency's concerns are addressed.

Federal regulators want DNR to show project wouldn't violate water quality, treaty rights

The EPA doesn't normally weigh in on state reviews, according to Jen Tyler, a supervisor who oversees federal environmental law within EPA’s Tribal Programs Office in Chicago. Tyler said the DNR invited the federal agency to weigh in on its draft. 

"EPA continues to have concerns about potential significant impacts, particularly to waters that are essential to the exercise of tribal treaty rights and continuation of tribal traditional lifeways," Tyler said. 

EPA staff told the DNR and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in letters this spring that the proposed project may have "substantial and unacceptable" impacts on the Bad River and Kakagon-Bad River Sloughs, which they say hold national and international importance. 

The EPA’s concerns about the project’s effects on high-quality waters and wetlands validate doubts expressed by tribal and environmental advocates, who argue the proposed route can’t be built without significant environmental harm. 

At Copper Falls State Park, the Tyler Forks River cascades down to join the Bad River. At a perch overlooking the falls, Tillison said the Bad River is one of few sites on Lake Superior that support spawning for lake sturgeon. And the Kakagon-Bad River Sloughs represents around 16,000 acres of internationally recognized wetlands. Federal officials say the sloughs are home to the largest wild rice bed on the Great Lakes. 

"That's really, really important to the Bad River tribal members. It's part of the migration story where they migrated to find the food that grows on water," said Tillison.
 

Brownstone Falls

The Tyler Forks River cascades down into the Bad River at Copper Falls State Park on Friday, June 24, 2022. Danielle Kaeding/WPR

The EPA wants the DNR to provide an analysis showing Enbridge's plans wouldn’t negatively affect state and tribal water quality standards. An Enbridge spokesperson said in a statement that input from agencies and the public will only make the project better. 

"Enbridge is committed to protecting the environment — and has proposed a 41-mile reroute, chosen because it minimizes environmental impacts and protects critical resources," said Michael Barnes, an Enbridge spokesperson. "Less than one-tenth of an acre of wetlands will be permanently impacted by the project." 

The EPA finds that impact is closer to 34 acres of mostly forested wetlands that would be permanently changed into emergent wetlands.

The EPA has also asked the state to further address how the project may affect tribal treaty rights to hunt, fish and gather along the route.

In 2019, a bipartisan group of lawmakers made it a felony for anyone to access an energy provider’s property without consent, with limited exceptions. 

 

Bad River

The Bad River tribe is suing Enbridge to remove the Canadian firm's Line 5 oil and gas pipeline from its reservation. 
Danielle Kaeding/WPR

Under that law, the Great Lakes Indian Fish and Wildlife Commission estimates the project would eliminate tribal access to roughly 43 acres of Iron County Forest.   

"For folks who just don't have a lot of resources, it is not in the best interest of tribes to diminish any sort of access," said Dawn White, a treaty resources specialist with the Commission who is also a Lac Courte Oreilles tribal member. "It would just be a big disservice for that alone." 

Enbridge has said the company will not bar tribal members from lawfully exercising treaty rights where the route crosses public land. However, the company said access to the route’s right-of-way will be restricted during pipeline construction to ensure public safety. The EPA wants the state to clarify where Enbridge would limit access during construction and operations. 

The risks of the project to groundwater is another concern. The pipeline also runs within 120 feet of at least 53 private wells. Iron County resident Bobbi Rongstad, who lives 40 acres from the proposed route, said she fears her well may be affected by drilling to install the pipeline during construction.

"If they hit one of those underground aquifers, that water can come spurting up at the surface," Rongstad said. "Then that aquifer might not be under pressure anymore, or the people who have their wells in that aquifer might not get water anymore."

Rongstad noted Enbridge breached aquifers during construction of the Line 3 replacement project in northern Minnesota. In March, the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources reported nearly 300 million gallons of groundwater had been released after crews ruptured three aquifers while building the line. 

 

Enbridge Line 3

WPR logo

Enbridge replaced its 1960s-era Line 3 pipeline across northern Minnesota amid multiple protests in the region. Photo courtesy of Enbridge

In a flood-prone region, pipeline could carry additional risks

In the past decade, northern Wisconsin has witnessed three floods that are only supposed to occur once every 500 to 1,000 years. 

Scientists have found climate change is increasing the frequency and intensity of rains, and environmental advocates say the state’s draft failed to fully account for those changing conditions. 

Evidence of the devastation could still be seen in the Bad River watershed as tribal and environmental advocates trekked through tall grass into a wooded ravine along the pipeline route. Joan Elias points out railroad tracks dangling in the air as Edwards Creek trickles along under them. 

Elias, who owns 190 acres near the proposed route, said she was temporarily stranded after around 10 inches of rain turned streams like this one into raging rivers one night in July 2016. 

Railroad tracks dangle in the air on Friday, June 24, 2022, where flooding in 2016 washed out banks underneath. Opponents of Enbridge's Line 5 reroute say the project faces more risks of a potential spill due to more frequent, intense storms driven by climate change. Danielle Kaeding/WPR

"It was washed out in both directions on Highway 169. It was washed out along little Edwards Road. It was washed out here," said Elias, noting it took months to repair some roads. 

The region's red clay soils don't quickly absorb water, causing rains to rapidly run off and scour the landscape. Opponents say more frequent, intense storms only increase the threat of a spill along the pipeline. 

"It's more likely to happen when there's going to be a storm and just more kinetic energy carrying a spill further downstream," said Tony Wilkin Gibart, executive director of Midwest Environmental Advocates. 

The risks of those changing conditions were highlighted when the Bad River tribe discovered a 40-foot span of Line 5 that became exposed in August of 2019. Tillison said the segment was mostly unsupported underneath as rapid flows quickly erode the region’s streams and riverbanks, especially after extreme storms. 

Naomi Tillison, the Bad River tribe's natural resources director, explains why tribal leaders decided to pursue action to remove Enbridge's Line 5 oil and gas pipeline from the tribe's reservation on Friday, June 24, 2022. Danielle Kaeding/WPR

Enbridge has said it will adhere to the best environmental practices, noting the company will utilize erosion control and spill prevention measures outlined in its environmental protection plan. While that plan includes detailed steps to address erosion and spills, it doesn’t reference climate change.

The EPA is recommending the DNR strengthen its review of the effects that climate change may have on the project, and how climate change affects the risk of erosion and exposure to the pipeline. Federal regulators also want the state to quantify direct and indirect greenhouse gas emissions for all routes proposed by Enbridge, including upstream and downstream emissions from oil and natural gas production to burning fossil fuels. 

Next steps for agencies permitting the project

The EPA doesn't have a lead role permitting the project. Even so, the agency is coordinating with the DNR and Army Corps, which is the federal agency permitting the project under the Clean Water Act.

The Army Corps is regulating construction-related activities in federal waters, as well as Enbridge’s proposal to drill underneath the White River. 

The Corps' Regulatory Division Deputy Chief Rebecca Graser said they’ve been working closely with the EPA to ensure that the agency is collecting information to address potential concerns. 

"Our goal is to make sure that the concerns that are addressed are resolved, whether it's under our authority, or whether it's under the state's authority," Graser said. 

The EPA's Tyler expects many of the agency’s recommendations will be addressed in the DNR’s final environmental impact statement, which federal regulators will review. The DNR said they’re addressing issues with those agencies, as well as other interested parties and Enbridge. 

A group of tribal and environmental advocates tour Enbridge's proposed route for its Line 5 project, routing a new 30-inch pipeline around the Bad River reservation. The group gathers where the pipeline would cross the Tyler Forks River on Friday, June 24, 2022. Danielle Kaeding/WPR

Ben Callan, who oversees a DNR team that reviews utility and energy projects, said the agency has received more than 30,000 comments on the company’s proposed route. That’s the most he’s seen in nearly two decades managing utility and energy projects.  

Meanwhile, Enbridge touted the economic benefits the project will have on the state and region. The company announced in April that Michels Pipeline, Inc. signed a letter of intent to be the main contractor for the project. The company is owned by Michels Corporation. Tim Michels announced his candidacy as a Republican running for governor against Gov. Tony Evers in April.  

"The project will be built by a Wisconsin contractor and a trained union workforce — creating 700 family-supporting union construction jobs," said Barnes. "An estimated $46 million will be spent specifically with Native-owned businesses and communities."

Enbridge experts have said in court filings that shutting down Line 5 would increase gas, diesel and jet fuel costs by an estimated $20 million each year in Wisconsin and $30 million annually in Michigan. Propane costs are anticipated to increase by at least $4 million per year for Wisconsin consumers and $38 million each year for Michigan customers.

 

Pipelines used to carry crude oil

 In this June 29, 2018 file photo, pipeline used to carry crude oil is shown at the Superior terminal of Enbridge Energy in Superior, Wis. Jim Mone/AP Photo 

A University of Wisconsin economics professor estimated an annual loss of more than 6,000 jobs and roughly $5 billion in lost economic output due to reduced production or closure of refineries in the Upper Midwest. Experts for the tribe dispute those findings. 

The Canadian firm stresses the 69-year-old pipeline is safe and a vital energy link for the region. Business Manager Joel Zielke with the Local 601 Steamfitters Union agrees. 

"That's a lot of gas and diesel and propane for people that really rely on that at this point still," said Zielke. "We know, someday, we will be able to disconnect ourselves from that, but we're not quite ready yet." 

Enbridge plans to break ground once all permits are granted. But it's clear federal regulators want to know much more before they make any final decisions.


Lakota Law Project

@lakotalaw

Image

https://twitter.com/lakotalaw


EVO MORALES CALLS FOR A GLOBAL CAMPAIGN TO ELIMINATE NATO

  • By Jeremy Kuzmarov, Covert Action Magazine.
  • July 31, 2022
  • Organize!

In Interview With British Journalist, Morales Says The U.S. Uses Nato To Provoke Wars And Sell Weapons.

U.S./Uk-Backed Coup Against Him In 2019 Was Undertaken For Lithium And Because His Government Advanced An Alternative Economic Model To The Neoliberal “Washington Consensus”.

In an interview with British journalist Matt Kennard at his home in El Trópico, a small town four hours from Cochabamba in the heart of the Amazon rain forest, former Bolivian president Evo Morales (2006-2019) called for an international campaign to eliminate NATO [the North Atlantic Treaty Organization].

According to Morales, this campaign should explain to people worldwide that “NATO is—ultimately—the United States. It is not a guarantee for humanity or for life. I do not accept—in fact, I condemn—how they can exclude Russia from the UN Human Rights Council. When the U.S. has intervened in Iraq, in Libya, in so many countries in recent years, why have they not been expelled from the Human Rights Council? Why was that never questioned?”

Morales continued: “We [in the Movimiento al Socialismo, MAS] have profound ideological differences with the politics implemented by the United States using NATO, which are based on interventionism and militarism. Between Russia and Ukraine they want to reach an agreement and [the U.S.] keeps provoking war, the U.S. military industry, which is able to live thanks to war, and they provoke wars in order to sell their weapons. That’s the other reality we live in.”

Coup Against Alternative Economic Model

Morales is one of the most successful presidents in Latin American history who closed down a U.S. military base in Bolivia, expelled the CIA and DEA, and helped reverse half a millennium of colonial history by helping Bolivia to industrialize its economy.

In November 2019, Morales was ousted in a U.S./UK-backed coup that culminated with the army’s massacre of anti-coup protesters. Morales survived an assassination attempt only because Mexico’s president, Andrés Manuel López Obrador, sent a plane to rescue him.

The beneficiary of the coup, Jeanine Áñez—a conservative Christian who lost the October 2020 election to Luis Arce of MAS—was sentenced to 10 years in prison in June after being convicted of terrorism and sedition.

Morales—who returned to Bolivia after Arce’s election in October 2020—believes that the coup was prompted by his move to nationalize Bolivia’s oil and gas reserves.

Morales told Matt Kennard that “I continue to be convinced that the empire, capitalism, imperialism, do not accept that there is an economic model that is better than neoliberalism. The coup was against our economic model…we showed that another Bolivia is possible.”

“All For Lithium”

In 2021, the British Foreign Office released documents which showed that the British embassy in Bolivia had paid an Oxford-based company to optimize “exploitation” of Bolivia’s lithium deposits the month after Morales fled the country after being ousted in the coup.

The documents also showed the UK embassy in La Paz acted as “strategic partner” to Áñez’ coup regime and organized an international mining event in Bolivia four months after democracy was overthrown.

Bolivia possesses the world’s second largest reserves of lithium, a metal used to make batteries, which has been increasingly coveted due to the burgeoning electric-car industry.

Under the traditional imperial dynamic which had kept Bolivia poor, rich countries extract raw materials, send them to Europe to be made into products, and then sell them back to Third World countries like Bolivia as finished products at a mark-up.

With Bolivia’s lithium deposits, Morales was adamant this system was finished. Bolivia would not just extract the lithium; it would build the batteries too. He told Kennard that:

“We started with a laboratory, obviously with international experts that we hired. Then we moved on to a pilot plant. We invested around $20 million, and now it’s working. Every year it produces about 200 tonnes of lithium carbonate, and lithium batteries, in Potosí [the capital of the Spanish empire where the Spanish had undertaken silver mining in the 17th, 18th and early 19th centuries.]”

Morales continued: “We had a plan to install 42 new [lithium] plants by 2029. It was estimated that profits would be five billion dollars. Profits! That’s when the coup came. The U.S. says China’s presence is not permitted but…having a market in China is very important. Also in Germany. The next step was with Russia, and then came the coup. Just last year, we found out that England had also participated in the coup—all for lithium.”

Colonial Mentality

When Kennard told Morales that the UK Foreign office had denied that a coup took place, Morales responded that this was hard to comprehend and reflected “a totally colonial mindset. They think that some countries are the property of other nations. They think God put them there, so the world belongs to the U.S. and the UK. That’s why the rebellions and the uprisings will continue.”

With The People Or The Evil Empire?

Morales has great admiration for Julian Assange whose detention, he said, “represents an escalation, an intimidation so that all the crimes against humanity committed by the different governments of the United States are never revealed. So many interventions, so many invasions, so much looting.”

Currently, Morales is working on building independent media in Bolivia, where he says that most of the media “belong to the empire or the right-wing.”

Optimistic about the recent victory of left-wing political forces in Peru, Chile and Colombia and Lula’s expected return to the presidency in Brazil, Morales told Kennard that, “in politics we must ask ourselves: Are we with the people or are we with the empire? If we are with the people, we make a country; if we are with the empire, we make money. If we are with the people, we fight for life, for humanity; if we are with the empire, we are with the politics of death, the culture of death, interventions, and pillaging of the people. That is what we ask ourselves as humans, as leaders: ‘Are we at the service of our people?’”


Yazzie to UN: Nuclear war doesn't start with detonation of bomb 

By Kathy Helms
Special correspondent
[email protected]
June 24, 2022
 
GRANTS – Janene Yazzie, a community organizer and human rights advocate from the Navajo Nation, this week joined colleagues at a United Nations meeting in Vienna, Austria, to discuss an international law banning nuclear weapons. 
 
Noticeably absent from the “First Meeting of State Parties to the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons” was the United States and the eight other nuclear weapons states.
 
In a message to “Relatives” and Navajo Nation leaders, Yazzie stated that she was attending the U.N. meeting as a member of the Nuclear Truth Project where she serves as coordinator of the Protocols Working Group. The working group presented the protocols it developed as a guiding framework for states, NGOs, researchers, and all actors working to implement the treaty and build a nuclear-free world.
 
“Even if the US has not signed the Treaty, it is still effectively International Law that will only continue to grow stronger with each new state that joins this global commitment [three more have joined in the last two days],” Yazzie told Navajo leaders.
 
Indigenous peoples have an “extraordinary opportunity” to lead meaningful actions and discussions in the United States, she said, “making our own commitments as sovereign nations, and holding our state accountable for the harms our communities continue to face from the legacy of uranium contamination and nuclear-related activities.”
 
U.S. missing in action
 
Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety in Santa Fe shared an article Thursday on its website authored by Ralph Hutchinson of Oak Ridge Environmental Peace Alliance, questioning why the United States was not participating in the meeting as an invited non-state party or sending observers. 
 
“First, what is the U.S. afraid of?” Hutchinson asked. “With a stockpile of more than 4,000 nuclear warheads and bombs, 1,500 of them deployed around the globe on hair-trigger alert, one would think the U.S. would be strong enough to walk into a room where the only weapons allowed are words and defend its position.”
 
Hutchinson said that if the United States is committed to pursue nuclear disarmament as it promised in the 1970 Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty, it should welcome the chance to talk about what that could look like – “all the nuclear armed nations coming to an agreement on protocols, verifications, and an enforceable timetable for eliminating nuclear stockpiles,” he said.
 
Threats condemned 
 
With Russian President Vladimir Putin's threats to use nuclear weapons in its war with Ukraine fresh on the world's collective mind, the states parties in the Vienna Declaration adopted Thursday, expressed their alarm and dismay at threats to use nuclear weapons, and condemned unequivocally “any and all nuclear threats, whether they be explicit or implicit and irrespective of the circumstances,” according to the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons.
 
The states parties resolved to move ahead with implementing all aspects of the treaty, including the positive obligations aimed at redressing the harm caused by nuclear weapons use and testing.
 
“In the face of the catastrophic risks posed by nuclear weapons and in the interest of the very survival of humanity ... We will not rest until the last state has joined the Treaty, the last warhead has been dismantled and destroyed and nuclear weapons have been totally eliminated from the Earth,” the Declaration states.
 
Irreparable harm
 
The impacts and consequences of nuclear war do not start with the detonation of a bomb, Yazzie said. “Nor does the mass murder that results from the nuclear weapons and in the aftermath, the impacts of the blast. Nuclear war, as my people understand it, and as many other people understand it, begins with the mining of uranium and the devastation to the health of our peoples and our environment. 
 
“That devastation and that impact and that legacy continues as long as our waters are undrinkable and our soils are contaminated and our babies are being born with uranium in their bodies or with birth defects due to the exposure of pregnant women to radioactive contamination,” she said.
 
Yazzie noted that she often has heard state delegates and even NGO representatives state that the potentiality of a future nuclear war “could be the end of our way of life,” a thought she can appreciate because of the footprint the legacy of uranium mining and nuclear testing has left on the Navajo Nation. 
 
“We can't drink the water available to us anymore. It means we can't gather the wild foods or grow the traditional foods that our communities have depended on for millennia,” Yazzie said. “It means that it's dangerous to live in the places of our ancestors, the place where the land knows our name, because it makes our people and our loved ones and our children sick. We do not have the technologies or the answers to fix those issues yet. 
 
“If this isn't experiencing the end of our way of life, I don't know what is,” she said.


Friends Committee On National Legislation logo

 

Support the Establishment of a Truth and Healing Commission on Indian Boarding Schools

https://fcnl.quorum.us/campaign/35660/
It is long overdue for the United States to acknowledge the historic trauma of the Indian boarding school era. In the 19th and early 20th centuries, Christian churches collaborated with the government to create hundreds of boarding schools for Native American children. The conditions at these schools, some of them Quaker-run, were unspeakable.
Now we must work with tribal nations to advance congressional efforts to establish a federal commission to formally investigate boarding school policy and develop recommendations for the government to take further action. Although the wrongs committed at these institutions can never be made right, we can start the truth, healing, and reconciliation process for the families and communities affected as we work to right relationship with tribal nations.
Remind your members of Congress of their responsibility to tribal nations and urge them to support the Truth and Healing Commission on Indian Boarding School Policies in the United States Act (S. 2907/H.R. 5444).

Bimaadiziwin Nibi - Water is Life

Water is Life Poster — Welcome to Honor The Earth Merchandise Store

A look into what Indigenous communities in the upper Midwest are doing to conserve & protect water

A Wisconsin Sea Grant and Great Lakes Indian Fish & Wildlife Commission collaboration

March 28, 2022

https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/5b3b9efd146744c3a50cf9d592e26d41


2022 National Week of Action for MMIW

Red faded background with white text 2022 National Week of Action for MMIW and partner logos in bottom footer.

The National Partners Work Group on Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW) and the MMIW Family Advisors are organizing a National Week of Action (April 29-May 5, 2022) to call the nation and the world to action in honor of missing and murdered Indigenous women. Take action by participating in these virtual events, exploring our list of resources, and organizing additional actions in your communities on and around May 5th. Join us in saying ‘enough is enough’—not one more stolen sister.


A MESSAGE FROM CHIEF ARVOL LOOKING HORSE

A “disease of the mind” has set in world leaders and many members of our global community, with their belief that a solution of retaliation and destruction of peoples will bring peace.

In our Prophecies it is told that we are now at the crossroads: Either unite spiritually as a global nation or be faced with chaos, disasters, diseases, and tears from our relatives’ eyes.

We are the only species that is destroying the source of life, meaning Mother Earth, in the name of power, mineral resources, and ownership of land. Using chemicals and methods of warfare that are doing irreversible damage, as Mother Earth is becoming tired and cannot sustain any more impacts of war.

I ask you to join me in this endeavor. Our vision is for the peoples of all continents, regardless of their beliefs in the Creator, to come together as one at their Sacred Sites.

Interior Department Renaming Sites With Offensive Native American Names

28 lakes, creeks, rivers and other geographical features in Wisconsin being renamed.

By Diane Bezucha, Wisconsin Public Radio - Apr 7th, 2022 
We think you will find our weekly email valuable.
DOI Secretary Deb Haaland. (Public Domain).

DOI Secretary Deb Haaland. (Public Domain).

The U.S. Department of the Interior is requesting public input on new names for more than 650 geographic features with racially offensive names.

Comments: https://www.regulations.gov/

In November, DOI Secretary Deb Haaland signed Secretarial Order 3404 declaring a word that originated as an Algonquin term for “woman” a derogatory name. Its meaning has shifted after centuries of use by white people as an offensive term for Indigenous women.

Melissa Doud, a program director with the Great Lakes Inter-Tribal Council and a member of the Lac du Flambeau Band of Lake Superior Chippewa, supports the order.

“It’s such a derogatory and negative thing to call a woman,” Doud said. “We’re resilient people, and it’s only fair to change the name to something that isn’t so racist.”

The federal order outlined steps for removing the term from federal and state lands, one of the steps included forming the Derogatory Geographic Names Task Force.

By March, the task force identified 664 geographical features — such as creeks, lakes, rivers and valleys — across the country that use the term and proposed five new names for each site. The complete list of places and their suggested new names are available as both a PDF and an interactive map.

The 28 sites in Wisconsin span 19 counties.

The federal government will manage the process, but the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources is helping to solicit input and will review proposed names to avoid duplicating the names of nearby geographic features.

 

While the DNR has its own council to handle geographic name changes, DNR Statewide Tribal Liaison Kris Goodwill said the process can be lengthy.

 

“That process can easily take over a year to get that accomplished. This kind of puts it on a fast track,” Goodwill said.

Under the new order, sites with the word in their title would bypass the state process.

But even before the order, many Wisconsin counties were already trying to eliminate the term.

In 2019, Dane County changed the name of a bay on Monona Lake to Wicawak, the Ho-Chunk word for muskrat. And last year, a lake in Oneida and Vilas counties near the Lac du Flambeau reservation was changed to Amber Lake.

John D. Johnson, Sr., president of the Lac du Flambeau Band of Lake Superior Chippewa, said the old name was a dishonor to Native women.

“Here in Lac du Flambeau — and I can speak for other reservations too — we put our women on a pedestal,” Johnson said. “We appreciate everything they do for us, because if it wasn’t for the woman, none of us would be here, right?”

People had been trying to change the name for more than 20 years, but nothing ever happened, Johnson said.

 

Then in 2020, a tribal member who happened to live on what is now Amber Lake approached Johnson about changing the name. They encountered some pushback from local residents, but Johnson said collaboration between the tribe and the lake’s association was key.

 

“What we did with the Lakes Association was pretty cool because they had come right to our (Tribal) Council room and we had talked together, we collaborated and that’s what needed to be done,” Johnson said.

Together they submitted a formal petition to the Wisconsin Geographic Names Council and about six months later, residents and tribal members had collectively renamed the lake Amber Lake.

Doud said they initially chose the name Ikwe, which means “woman” in Ojibwe, but some residents felt it might be difficult to pronounce. Together they agreed on Amber because of the golden color of the Tamarack trees that surround the lake.

Now communities will have the backing of the federal government to speed up the process. And the movement to remove offensive terms from geographic features will not stop with this one word.

In November, Haaland also signed Secretarial Order 3405, creating a federal advisory committee that will identify and recommend new names for sites that use other racial slurs and derogatory terms. In the past, similar bodies have renamed geographic features that used the N-word or a pejorative term for Japanese people.

 

The committee has yet to be formed, but Goodwill said it could consider renaming features such as a rapid on the Tomahawk River that has a name that uses a derogatory term for someone who is of mixed race.

 

“This is a good move for the future. I think it’s overdue,” said Goodwill, who is a member of the Menominee Nation. “I think it goes along with having our first Native American secretary of the Interior.”

Public input on the current list will be accepted until April 25. You can submit comments online, using the docket number DOI-2022-0001. You can also mail your written comments to: Reconciliation of Derogatory Geographic Names, MS-511, U.S. Geological Survey, 12201 Sunrise Valley Dr., Reston, VA 20192. Be sure to include the docket number.

Listen to the WPR report here.

‘A good move for the future’: Federal officials ask for public input in renaming 28 sites with derogatory names in Wisconsin was originally published by Wisconsin Public Radio.


NO MORE PIPELINE BLUES (ON THIS LAND WHERE WE BELONG)

NO MORE PIPELINE BLUES (ON THIS LAND WHERE WE BELONG) 

FEATURING WAUBANEWQUAY, WINONA LADUKE, DAY SISTERS, MUMU FRESH, PURA FE, SONI MORENO, JENNIFER KREISBERG, INDIGO GIRLS, BONNIE RAITT AND JOY HARJO.

https://youtu.be/zjoRB7ETaGk

Film Directed by Keri Pickett | Edited by River Akemann & Keri Pickett
Music Written & Produced by Larry Long  | Recorded by Brett Huus
Cinematographers: Sarah Littleredfeather, River Akemann & Keri Pickett

SHUT DOWN ENBRIDGE LINE 5/Coalition Challenging the Straits Sunken Hazard

WE NEED YOUR HELP IN WI!
ACTION ALERT: The EPA is now telling us that Enbridge's plan to build a pipeline through northern WI stands to permanently damage our water.
"Application and related information that EPA reviewed, we believe that the proposed project “may result in substantial and unacceptable adverse impacts” to the Bad River and the Kakagon- Bad River Sloughs wetland complex ... and may permanently and negatively impact water quality, aquatic life, and native habitat,” the EPA wrote.
PLEASE EMAIL THE WI DNR and tell them to Just Say No to Line 5!
Department of Natural Resources Line 5 EIS Comments (EA/7) 101 South Webster Street, Madison, WI 53707
Email: [email protected]
#StopLine5
#DefendTheSacred
#WaterIsLife
#HonorTheEarth
#HonorTheTreaties
#lastrealindian

It’s past time to release Leonard Peltier

peltier600.jpg

By Gerry Adams (for Léargas)

This Christmas take a moment to think about Leonard Peltier.

Leonard was convicted in 1977 of the murder in 1975 of two FBI agents during a confrontation at the Pine Ridge Reservation in South Dakota. Two others who were charged with the murders were found not guilty by reason of self-defence. Peltier has always denied involvement in the two deaths. He has been in prison for almost 45 years.

In the years since then serious and significant questions have arisen over the evidence produced by the prosecution at the trial. A witness who recanted her account claimed she had been forced into making a statement by the FBI. A ballistics expert who linked Peltier’s weapon to the murders was reprimanded by the federal court for lying.

In July this year James H. Reynolds, the former US Attorney General whose office handled the prosecution and appeal in the Leonard Peltier case, appealed for his sentence to be commuted. In a letter to President Joe Biden he said: “With time, and the benefit of hindsight, I have realised that the prosecution and continued incarceration of Mr Peltier was and is unjust.”

In October Amnesty International issued an Urgent Action notice calling for clemency for Leonard Peltier. Amnesty pointed out that “Leonard Peltier has been imprisoned in the USA for over 44 years, some of which was spent in solitary confinement, serving two life sentences for murder despite concerns over the fairness of his trial. He has always maintained his innocence. He is 77 years old and suffers from a number of chronic health ailments, including one that is potentially fatal.”

“In October US Congress members Raúl M. Grijalva, Barbara Lee, Jesús Garcia, Cori Bush, Emanuel Cleaver II, Jared Huffman, Teresa Leger Fernández, Rashida Tlaib, Pramila Jayapal, Betty McCollum, and Melanie Stansbury — wrote a joint letter to you requesting the expedited release of Leonard Peltier from the Coleman Federal Correctional Complex in Florida and requesting that Mr Peltier be granted clemency.”

Calls for Leonard Peltier’s release have also been supported by international figures, including the late Nelson Mandela, former Irish President Mary Robinson and Archbishop Desmond Tutu.

Join us in urging compassion and clemency for Leonard Peltier. Write to:
President Joseph Biden
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Ave NW
Washington, DC 20500, USA.

Native Lives Matter

Native Lives Matter goes beyond police brutality to also include social and environmental injustice, MMIW, and protection of women & water. Discussion and bringing about awareness of the police brutality and Injustice occurring within Indian Country and working towards solutions.
Inspire and support the activist movement of Native Lives Matter to be the catalyst of change and create longstanding solutions within our law enforcement & judicial systems.
Direct Action
Standing in support and advocate for the families and victims who have experienced, police brutality loss of family and injustice.
Standing in solidarity to honor ancestors of the past in remembrance & memorials.
Solidarity with Missing & Murdered Indigenous Women

National Day of Awareness for Missing & Murdered Indigenous Women, Girls, 2 Spirit Thursday, May 5, 2022

Native Lives Matter | Justice for MMIW • Artwork b | Mmiw awareness quotes,  Black lives matter quotes, Lives matter

#VAWA -VAWA Law: Protections and rights to prosecute non-natives who abuse our Women on Tribal Lands. End the Violence Against Women, End the Sexual Assault against Indigenous Native Women.
Native Lives Matter Coalition-consists of multiple groups and organizations that support in collaboration.
https://www.facebook.com/nlmcoalition
Women Of The White Buffalo
https://womenofthewhitebuffalo.com/home/
Feature documentary film and ‘Leica’ sponsored photography of the Native American Lakota Nation. Produced by Deborah Anderson Creative. 
Delacina Chief Eagle is one of the women featured in the soon to be released feature documentary film Women Of The White Buffalo.
Save the date! This powerful and important feature documentary film is coming out April 12th!!

LN3: Seven Teachings of the Anishinaabe in Resistance

https://www.facebook.com/events/782757979786820/?acontext=%7B%22event_action_history%22%3A[%7B%22mechanism%22%3A%22search_results%22%2C%22surface%22%3A%22search%22%7D]%2C%22ref_notif_type%22%3Anull%7D

The South Shore of Lake Superior and Line 5: Impacts

https://www.facebook.com/RejectLine5/videos/1050867815489741

Shut Down Line 5 - Protect the Water!

https://www.facebook.com/WinonaLaDukeHonorTheEarth/videos/313448660748647


Menominee Indian Tribe No Back 40 Mine

https://www.facebook.com/NoBack40Mine

The Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin, a federally recognized Indian Tribe, is indigenous to what is now known as Wisconsin and Upper Michigan. By the early 1800’s, the start of the treaty era, the Menominee occupied a land base estimated at 10 million acres; however, through a series of seven treaties entered into with the United States Government during the 1800’s, the Tribe witnessed its land base erode to little more than 235,000 acres today.

Our sacred place of origin exists within our 1836 treaty territory, at the mouth of the Menominee River which is located in the border cities of Menominee, MI and Marinette, WI. It was here, a mere 60 miles east of our present Menominee Indian Reservation, where our five main clans: ancestral Bear, Eagle, Wolf, Moose and Crane were transformed into human form and thus became the first Menominee.

As a result of our undeniable ties and long occupation of the Menominee River area, we have numerous sacred sites and burial mounds up and down the Menominee River, including the area of the proposed Back Forty Mine. Much like our brothers and sister in the NODAPL movement we also know that water is essential to life. The Menominee River is, in fact, the very origin of life for the Menominee people. It also provides life to Michigan and Wisconsin residents and the natural wildlife within the Great Lakes ecosystem. The harmful threats to this area and all who depend on it far outweigh the corporate interests of a Canadian exploratory company and justify the denial of the necessary permits for the proposed mine.

The Menominee Nation is steadfast in its opposition to the proposed mine and its commitment to preserving the Menominee River. We ask you to stand in solidarity with us as we continue our fight to protect our place of origin, our sacred sites, the wildlife, water and environment for future generations.

 


White Mesa Mill - header(Alastair Lee Bitsóí | The Salt Lake Tribune) White Mesa residents and anti-uranium activists march, pray and sing as part of the annual spiritual walk in protest of the White Mesa Mill, Oct. 9, 2021.

 

https://www.grandcanyontrust.org/white-mesa-uranium-mill

https://www.facebook.com/yo.nuche/videos/409028270945404

white mesa say's NO to uranium

This group is to help white Mesa community fight!! Against the uranium mill that's only 3miles from the rez line.. This stuff has got in to the water.. They want to expand the mill where there is sacred burial sites, please all I ask is for your support.

EPA faults uranium processor for not keeping Superfund waste covered

Energy Fuels Resources barred from accepting some radioactive material after federal authorities conclude the White Mesa facility has not been properly storing dangerous waste.

Clean Up The Mines

https://www.facebook.com/cleanupthemines

@cleanupthemines  · Community
A national campaign to clean up thousands of toxic abandoned uranium mines throughout the U.S. that poison our the air, land & water.
Irresponsible corporations and negligent government agencies have abandoned thousands of toxic uranium mines throughout the US. These hazardous abandoned uranium mines poison our air, land and water. Currently no laws require clean up of these dangerous sites. Together we can safeguard our health and environment.

 

 

A vibrant group of people in colorful clothing stands outdoors near Alcatraz, holding musical instruments and flags. They seem to be part of a cultural event or gathering, celebrating their heritage with music and unity.
Indigenous leaders lead collective prayers at the annual sunrise gathering on Alcatraz Island. Photo on Oct. 14, 2024 by Abigail Van Neely.

  • Sign in


Powered by people like you
Harold Mesa John Zakrzewski Jonathan Ward Aida Porteneuve SafeSoundMke One Good Thing Today Kawkab Al-Thaibani Wisconsin Cuba Coalition People For Assange Our Wisconsin Revolution T.M. Antonis (Ms. Cat) Andrew Meindl James Balk Laura Lynch Gilbert Colon Taylor (she/her)
Harold Mesa John Zakrzewski Jonathan Ward Aida Porteneuve SafeSoundMke One Good Thing Today Kawkab Al-Thaibani Wisconsin Cuba Coalition People For Assange Our Wisconsin Revolution

Facebook—Twitter

Sign in. Created with NationBuilder